Dropping Things Into The Sun is Hard....
Channel:Scott Manley · Length:6:39 · Published:2015-12-10 · Views:518893
Summary
Scott Manley uses a realistically scaled Kerbal Space Program setup to show why dropping something into the Sun is far harder than it sounds. It demonstrates the need to cancel orbital velocity.
Why HN recommends it
Cited whenever someone suggests launching nuclear waste or other junk into the Sun, as a clear demonstration of the orbital mechanics involved.
Or watch Scott Manley demonstrate the unreasonable orbital dynamics you just described. — HN, 2017
Fundamental physics · Space exploration & spaceflight
Subtitles (excerpt)
[Intro music] Hello, it's Scott Manley here, responding to a cry for help from NerdCubed. NerdCubed, of course, has been doing his summaries of the year, including his steaming pile of poop games, which featured at number one the horrific specter of awfulness that is Galactic Hitman. At the end, he said this game is so bad, it could be weaponized, and therefore the best solution for the safety of the world would be to consign all copies of this terrible piece of so-called entertainment to the heart of the Sun, where they will be destroyed and hopefully lost to the universe forevermore. And so I decided to attempt to simulate this act of mercy using Kerbal Space Program and, more importantly, using Realistic-Scale Solar System, which, of course, has everything real size, so we wouldn't be some little Kerbal solar system. No, this would be a real-size solar system with real delta-Vs and everything. I built a rocket that had about, you know, 17, 18 kilometers per second of delta-V, and, well, unfortunately ran out of fuel before I managed to get the thing too close to the Sun. In fact, as you may well know, the biggest problem with dropping stuff into the Sun is the fact that we're moving around the Sun
On Hacker News
> play Kerbal Space Program. Or watch Scott Manley demonstrate the unreasonable orbital dynamics you just described. [VIDEO] — pdkl95, 2017-03
Also, what happens to the stuff we toss into space? People still seem to make the same mistake our ancestors did regarding tossing stuff into the ocean. To be more precise: achieving a velocity high enough to e.g. detonate on the surface of the sun (in particular carrying tons of nuclear waste) won't be cheap for a long time. [1] Stuff we "toss out there" would probably just keep floating in an u… — bipson, 2019-08
> You could potentially dump some energy with a gravitational assist off of Venus (transfer some of our momentum into speeding up its orbit while slowing ours down) I've heard that a hard turn around Jupiter is even better. I remember Scott Manley dropping a probe into Kerbol via Jool gravity assist in one video[0]. Actually, now I want to make a simulation with Earth doing Jupiter flybys. What's… — TeMPOraL, 2016-05
My idea is just figure out a way to nudge earth towards the sun and inertia will do the rest ARRGH! This is about as big a misunderstanding as not knowing the difference between sending a rocket to space vs. getting to orbit: [VIDEO] tl;dr -- the Earth is whizzing around the Sun at a really high speed. You'd have to cancel most of that velocity to get a spacecraft to get anywhere near the Sun. It… — stcredzero, 2016-05
Related videos
- Gender Neutral Pronouns: They're Here, Get Used To Them · Tom Scott · 3:48
- BlueHat IL 2019 - Andrew "bunnie" Huang - Supply Chain Security: "If I were a Nation State...” · Microsoft Israel R&D Center · 45:37
- But what is the Fourier Transform? A visual introduction. · 3Blue1Brown · 19:41
- Cybersecurity as Realpolitik by Dan Geer presented at Black Hat USA 2014 · Black Hat · 54:35
- Mark Blyth ─ Global Trumpism · Watson School of International and Public Affairs · 1:26:03
- Chernobyl 3828 · TeleconStudio · 26:57
- Flat Earth: A Measured Response · hbomberguy · 45:17
- TasBlock at AGDQ 2017: TASBot · TASVideosChannel · 58:44
- George Lakoff: Moral Politics · University of California Television (UCTV) · 58:57
- Tom Lehrer - Wernher von Braun · The Tom Lehrer Wisdom Channel · 1:46
- Congressional Fundraising: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO) · LastWeekTonight · 21:25
- DCEmu Reviews - 27C3 - Chaos Communication Congress 2010 - fail0verflow - FULL VIDEO · 1KIND Reviews · 44:39
- They're Made Out of Meat · niccollsdp · 6:16
- Hovering a Helicopter is Hilariously Hard - Smarter Every Day 145 · SmarterEveryDay · 9:45
- Data | Philosophy Tube · Philosophy Tube · 26:14
- The Alt-Right Playbook: Control the Conversation · Innuendo Studios · 10:47
- Super Mario World -- Credits Warp in 5:59.6 (First Time Ever on Console) · SethBling · 9:00
- Deadly Truth of General AI? - Computerphile · Computerphile · 8:30
- Velocity NY 2013: Richard Cook, "Resilience In Complex Adaptive Systems" · O'Reilly · 19:09
- The more general uncertainty principle, regarding Fourier transforms · 3Blue1Brown · 18:06