Dual Photography

Channel:mm648230 · Length:5:10 · Published:2009-03-28 · Views:24505

Watch on YouTube

Summary

The SIGGRAPH 2005 demo of dual photography from Stanford, which swaps the roles of projector and camera to render a scene from the light's point of view. It includes the reveal of a hidden playing card.

Why HN recommends it

Cited whenever threads discuss recovering hidden images or non-line-of-sight imaging, as a clear demonstration of light transport.

Skip ahead to 4:19 for a succinct demo. — HN, 2014

Computer vision, speech & NLP · Computer graphics & rendering

Subtitles (excerpt)

our technique allows us to Interchange cameras and projectors thereby enabling us to take images from the point of view of a projector suppose for example we had the following experimental setup here we have a scene that is imaged by a camera on the left and illuminated by a projector on the right this is the image taken by the camera which shows the scene flood illuminated by the projector in our paper we refer to this as the Primal image after measuring the light transport between the projector and the camera we show that the flow of light can be effectively reversed using hel hols reciprocity this means that we are able to generate an image from the point of view of the projector as shown here this dual image shows the scene from the perspective of the projector while illumination is coming from the position of the camera note that this is the image synthesized by our technique dual photography is the process of measuring the light transport to generate the Dual image a simple example will help us understand how dual photography works this scene is illuminated by a projector and the outgoing light will be measured by a photo sensor suppose we light up a single Pixel at a time in the projector and store the value measured by

On Hacker News

Dual Photography has always been the optical "trick" that's blown me away. Here's the demo video from Siggraph in 2005: [VIDEO] Skip ahead to 4:19 for a succinct demo. — uptown, 2014-05
> Does anyone assert that any photon carries information about what it interacted with in the past? Does a photon have any information content other than its energy/wavelength? So "each one carries a bit of the image of whatever it hits" is total (ok, be nice now) poetic blarney. An analogy to how we perceive things seems appropriate. The light from some source (i.e the sun) hits an object, the l… — saeranv, 2020-06
It sounds like "Dual Photography". [LINK] "We present a novel photographic technique called dual photography, which exploits Helmholtz reciprocity to interchange the lights and cameras in a scene. With a video projector providing structured illumination, reciprocity permits us to generate pictures from the viewpoint of the projector, even though no camera was present at that location." I recommen… — pdkl95, 2020-02
This reminds me of dual photography [1], in which you trade many projectors and one camera for one projector and many cameras using time reversal symmetry. The video [2] gives a good explanation, and the revelation of the playing card is what strikes me as similar to revealing reflected hidden faces. [1] [LINK] [2] [VIDEO] — evanb, 2013-12
I've never forgotten this SIGGRAPH demo from almost twenty years ago, in which the authors effectively switch camera and light source computationally (... in a static scene) [1] Ever since then, I have viewed scenes such as the "lingerie store scene" from Enemy of the State [2] with a little bit less eye rolling... [1] - [VIDEO] [2] - [LINK] — janfoeh, 2026-05

Related videos