Noam Chomsky Stumps Andrew Marr

Channel:Unapproved Narratives · Length:3:07 · Published:2016-08-31 · Views:275180

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A three-minute clip of Noam Chomsky in an exchange with BBC journalist Andrew Marr about media filtering and self-censorship. Chomsky argues that people reach positions precisely because they would not say things that conflict with the system.

Why HN recommends it

Cited as the source of Chomsky's 'you wouldn't be sitting where you're sitting' line in threads on media bias and corporate employees defending their employers.

I'm not saying you're self-censoring; I'm sure you believe everything you're saying. — HN, 2021

Free speech, censorship & civil liberties · Media, journalism & propaganda

Subtitles (excerpt)

is a a censoring organization. Um tell me how that works. Is it you you're not suggesting that um proprietors phone one another up or that many journalists get their copy spiked, as we say? It's um actually Orwell you may recall has an essay called Literary Censorship in England, which was supposed to be the introduction to Animal Farm, except that it never appeared. And which he points out, "Look, I'm writing about a totalitarian society, but in free democratic England it's not all that different." And then he says uh unpopular ideas can be silenced without any force. And then How how can you two He gives a two-sentence response, which is not very profound, but captures it. He says two reasons. First, the press is owned by wealthy men who have every interest in not having certain things appear, but second, the whole educational system from the beginning on through just ex- gets you to understand that there are certain things you just don't say. Well, spelling these things out, that's perfectly correct. I mean, there it's the first sentence is what we expand on. This is what I don't get, because it suggests that I mean, I'm a journalist, people like me are self-censoring. No, not self-censoring. Uh you're There's a filtering system that starts in

On Hacker News

> Thus (not having read it myself), Manufacturing Consent could show how emergent properties of mass media might lead to them pushing a certain incorrect world view, rather than proposing a theory that requires the teams behind them to all agree to conspire and none of them to make that public knowledge. That is right. Chomsky proposes 5 filters through which this process happens. These filters o… — herbstein, 2019-03
I believe this [1] should be the interview, found it via leaving out the quotes and using "Chomsky" instead of "Noam". [1] [VIDEO] — r0uv3n, 2022-09
"I'm not saying you're self-censoring; I'm sure you believe everything you're saying. What I'm saying is that if you believed something different you wouldn't be sitting where you're sitting." [VIDEO] — aahortwwy, 2021-08
Herman & Chomsky's "Manufacturing Consent" proposes the method through which the media influence isn't by way of "old men in a dark, smoky backroom" as the claim conjures images of. Rather, it's a series of filters that funnel like-minded people into the decision-making roles of the companies. If we simplify it a lot, it's the claim that a CEO is very likely to hire a senior editor that shares hi… — herbstein, 2021-08
Noam Chomsky with Andrew Marr [VIDEO] "If you believed something different, you wouldn't be sitting where you are sitting" — chacha2, 2021-03

Related videos