There's No Crying in Flag Design

Channel:CGP Grey · Length:18:53 · Published:2023-04-02 · Views:20879377

Watch on YouTube

Summary

CGP Grey discusses flag design principles and grades flags, following the Minnesota state flag redesign. It argues for simple, distinctive flags.

Why HN recommends it

Linked whenever flag redesigns come up, and credited as hugely influential on how people think about flag design.

This one video has had more influance on flag design than any written editorial. — HN, 2026

Graphic design & typography

Subtitles (excerpt)

[school bell rings] Hello, class. Your homework assignment as the U.S. states that you are was to make your state flag. A flag to stir pride in your citizens. A flag to stand proud on the American stage. A tough task, though not too tough with the guidelines I gave you upon which you will be graded. One. Keep it simple. Something a child could draw. Even if they need to simplify it again. Good enough. Two. Make it distinct at a distance. A flag is not a poster, it’s not wallpaper, it’s not a patch, it’s not money, or anything else looked at up close. No tiny details. It's a flag. It will be flying from afar among other flags and when the wind stops, you still need to be able to spot yours. Three colors or fewer unless you really know what you're doing. But if you think you do, you probably don't. Four. Symbols. Have them. Your colors and what you design with them should mean something. It should say something about your citizens. Five. Words on a flag. The ideal number is zero. It's a flag, not a note that you're passing in class. Thank you. I'll take that. If you violated this rule, I hope you hid those words in a design because you will be marked down. And there is one thing you are absolutely forbidden from writing.

On Hacker News

An article about flag design but no mention of CGP Grey? This one video has had more influance on flag design than any written editorial. [VIDEO] — sandworm101, 2026-06
It is a useful concept, and letting the whispers of the vexillophiles[0] into your head will lead you to see that most flags are well, pretty bad. CGP Grey has a lot of opinions[1] about this. [0] [LINK] [1] [VIDEO] — jonchurch_, 2025-04
Obligatory link to CGP Grey's grading of the quality of all U.S. state flags: [VIDEO] Also, a more recent video about Minnesota's new flag: [LINK] — ubj, 2023-12
On a related topic, here [1] is a video of CGP Grey grading US flags. My flag Wyoming gets an F in the S tier. But I am happy he wants to retire here. [Spoiler] Utah is one of 4 states that gets the highest grade. [1] - [VIDEO] [video][19 mins] — LinuxBender, 2023-04
That thing is supposed to be a logo? I'm reminded of CGP Gray's videos about flags. [LINK] Like this one [VIDEO] About US state flags — mjevans, 2024-09

Related videos