Nord Stream sabotage and hybrid war on Europe

Channel:Anders Puck Nielsen · Length:13:42 · Published:2022-10-04 · Views:168105

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Anders Puck Nielsen analyzes the Nord Stream pipeline sabotage using Kilcullen's theory of liminal warfare and prospect theory. He argues from the operational design that Russia is the most likely culprit, then discusses how hybrid warfare might be used against Europe.

Why HN recommends it

HN points to it as a compact, reasoned case for Russian responsibility, though at least one commenter found the argument unconvincing.

Anders Puck Nielsen has an under 15 minute video with a compelling explanation for why Russia is most likely to have done it — HN, 2023

Geopolitics & foreign policy · Military history & warfare

Subtitles (excerpt)

In this video I want to talk about the attacks on the Nord Stream pipelines in the Baltic Sea. There has been a lot of speculation about who was behind it. And the thing is, there is no evidence for anything, at least not yet. So we don't know who did it. But I do think that we can say some things about the operational design of the attack and the choices that were made. And this says something about what the purpose must have been. And if we have an idea about the purpose of the attack, then we also have a good indication of who did it. And I'll save you the suspense. I think Russia did it. So what I want to do is to explain why. And it's going to be a little geeky, because I am going to use military theory to make the argument. And then, I will also share some thoughts about the possible meaning of the attack. Because I think many people in the West have a wrong perception about how serious this crisis is, and how bad it can get. I don't know how the Nord Stream pipelines blew up. And maybe we will never know. But I do think the operational design is interesting. Because when you plan such an act of sabotage, you make some important choices. And these choices reveal a lot about what you want to achieve.

On Hacker News

Anders Puck Nielsen has an under 15 minute video with a compelling explanation for why Russia is most likely to have done it despite the obvious downsides. Just to pick some particular details: At this particular time the primary Russian strategy was to push Europe into a cold and dark winter. Pipelines can be rebuilt and that is not especially difficult when you are making big money from extract… — m0llusk, 2023-03
The Anders Puck Nelson video about this came to the conclusion that it was probably Russia. His reasoning is interesting. [VIDEO] — m0llusk, 2023-02
> what is the most articulate and sensible piece on why the most likely culprit is Russia? I think this video is articulate and sensible: [VIDEO] — Const-me, 2023-02
That cause for that event is not undisputed, see [LINK] . You still haven't explained why you think it's doubtful Russia would use sabotage in this way. This is what their entire modus operandi, just think of the various Polonium-210 and Novichok operations. You can't dispute that people are suspecting USA of having done it, does that not harm cohesion inside NATO? [VIDEO] — j0057, 2022-11
He said at the start of that video he discussed his belief about the probability of Russia attacking was covered in this video [VIDEO] > They want people to be panicked by their hybrid warfare Why? People were already panicking about Russia (rolling through Western Europe, using nukes, etc). The argument in the video I linked is not very convincing to me at all. Nobody was ever under any doubt th… — throwawaylinux, 2023-02

Related videos