Winners Take All | Anand Giridharadas | Talks at Google

Channel:Talks at Google · Length:1:00:56 · Published:2018-10-19 · Views:252690

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Anand Giridharadas presents his book Winners Take All at Google, arguing that the global elite's philanthropy and 'win-win' framing preserve the systems that create inequity. He challenges the audience, including Google employees, to examine their own role in that system.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters recommend it as a pointed critique of philanthropy and win-win thinking, delivered inside Google itself, and cite it across threads on wealth, tax and tech power.

I strongly encourage everyone - especialy anyone employed at Google - to watch it. — HN, 2019

Tech industry & business models · Labor, work & inequality

Subtitles (excerpt)

[MUSIC PLAYING] ANAND GIRIDHARADAS: Thank you for having me. Look, we all recognize the awkwardness of me talking about the elite charade of changing the world at Google. So let's just name that upfront, and be aware of that, and be aware of our complicated feelings we may have. This is going to be like therapy. I want to start by laying out some kind of propositions to you, and I say this in a spirit of sharing with you some of what I've found as I spent the last three years thinking about what happens when the winners of our age move with great sincerity to try to solve some of our biggest societal problems, but also, in my view, end up having an effect that they don't sometimes understand, which is changing how we think about change, and redefining change in ways that makes it friendly to winners and makes it hard to make real change. I'm going to advance some of these propositions, and then I'd really love to have a dialogue with you, because we are here in the belly of the beast. The first proposition is that we live in an age of extraordinary generosity by any measure. Some of you may just have seen the Bezos announcement a couple hours ago, which only is the latest installment

On Hacker News

If you're genuinely curious, a few suggestions that I personally found incredibly enlightening: Anand Giridhardas, Winners Take All: The book is fantastic, there's also his now infamous google talk where he talks about dismantling google: [VIDEO] Thomas Piketty, Capital in the 21st century: Probably the most comprehensive (but at times also longwinded) outline on how wealth inequality comes to be… — abuob, 2026-06
> It's way nicer on our side, where we do win-win deals, and know to be happy, the people around us need to be happy. If you would like this world-view to undergo some critical analysis, I strongly recommend Anand Giridharadas' take in "Winners take All" (condensed in this google-talk here: [VIDEO] ). He specifically addresses the negative points of the "win-win"-mentality, and in my opinion, mak… — Shacklz, 2021-04
> But a system of philanthropy is inherently biased insofar as since donors can and do choose charitable causes that match their own preferences. Anand Giridharadas goes pretty deeply into that idea in this talk that he did at Google. I highly recommend watching it, I thought it was elucidating. [VIDEO] I want to read his book "Winners Take All: The Elite Charade of Changing the World" but I have… — CharlesColeman, 2019-03
One of the best explanations why "philanthropy" and "novel (disrupting), win-win solutions" for systemic problems is highly anti-democratic (and inciting class warfare) is Anand Giridharadas's recent talk[1] at Google[2]. I strongly encourage everyone - especialy anyone employed at Google - to watch it. [1] [VIDEO] [2] Google is the perfect venue for this talk. — pdkl95, 2019-02
Giridharadas talk is explosive in terms of its ideas. From what I can tell, he's not pulling any punches even though he's been invited to speak on a Google campus (Boston). At 29:03 Giridharadas challenges his audience to demand that Google (and other Silicon Valley companies) generate an annual political disclosure to its employees, the very people in his audience. [0] As a side note, Giridharad… — mistersquid, 2018-10

Related videos