Reagan and Bush Debate Immigration, Border Fences, and Undocumented Children in 1980

Channel:TIME · Length:2:51 · Published:2017-02-03 · Views:912143

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short clip of George H. W. Bush and Ronald Reagan answering an audience question on illegal immigration at a 1980 Republican primary debate. Both take notably sympathetic positions, including on schooling for undocumented children.

Why HN recommends it

Repeatedly posted in immigration threads to contrast 1980 Republican rhetoric with modern positions.

Reminded me of a fascinating video I recall; Bush and Reagan debate illegal immigration in 1980's primary. — HN, 2024

US politics & elections · Social issues & culture

Subtitles (excerpt)

[AUDIENCE]: Yes, my name's David Grossberg, and I'd like to know. Do you think the children of illegal aliens should be allowed to attend Texas public schools free, or do you think that their parents should pay for their education? [BUSH]: Who are you addressing that to? [MODERATOR SMITH]: I think you're first in this (uh) ... [REAGAN]: He's looking right at you. [BUSH]: I'd say that he was. [MODERATOR SMITH]: (laughs). [BUSH]: Look, I'd like to see something done about the illegal alien problem that would be so sensitive and so understanding about labor needs, and human needs, that that problem wouldn't come up, but today, if those people are here, (err) I (would reluctantly say, I) think (they would) they would get whatever it (is that they're, you know what) the society is giving to their neighbors, but (it has) the problem has to be solved. The problem has to be solved because, with, as we had (kind of) made illegal some kinds of labor that I'd like to see legal, we're doing two things. [Firstly,] we're creating a whole society of really honorable, decent, family-loving people that are in violation of the law, and secondly, we're exacerbating relations with Mexico. (inaudible) The answer [to] your question is much more fundamental

On Hacker News

> A position that was considered conservative in the 1980's is likely not conservative a generation and a half later. If you want a really jarring example of this, watch Bush (Sr.) and Reagan debate immigration during the 1980 primaries. [VIDEO] They sound like Democrats today. (And that's in the primaries , where people tend to be more party-line!) — ceejayoz, 2025-10
> Go over to YouTube and bring up some Reagan-Mondale or Clinton-Bush debates and compare their tone and temperament to what we see today. Reminded me of a fascinating video I recall; Bush and Reagan debate illegal immigration in 1980's primary. [VIDEO] They sound more liberal than half of today's Democrats. — ceejayoz, 2024-01
I have a suspicion that it’s no different than any other highly efficient system. You’ll notice that every time there’s a natural crisis you’ll hear how facility X is the only place in the world where Y is done and now everything Y is going to go up in price[0]. There’s lots of reasons everyone downstream of X doesn’t have backup plans but one that certainly applies to the immediate consumers of … — arjie, 2026-03
Here’s some American context: a ~3 minute video. Bush and Reagan, during the primaries, trying to win over Republicans, answering a question about immigration. [VIDEO] That’s what American conservatism used to look like. Modern Dems talk a lot like that. — ceejayoz, 2025-11
Check out how they used to talk about immigrants. Here’s Reagan and Bush debating the issue in the 80s. You’d mistake them for Dems today. [VIDEO] — ceejayoz, 2025-09

Related videos