The more general uncertainty principle, regarding Fourier transforms
Channel:3Blue1Brown · Length:18:06 · Published:2018-02-25 · Views:2355719
Summary
3Blue1Brown shows how the uncertainty principle arises from Fourier transforms. A wave packet cannot be narrow in both position and frequency, so the principle is a property of waves rather than of measurement.
Why HN recommends it
HN recommends it as the clearest visual explanation that uncertainty is intrinsic to waves, separate from measurement disturbance.
The clearest, most intuitive explanation of the Fourier Uncertainty Principle that I have come across is by Grant Sanderson of 3Blue1Brown. — HN, 2024
Recreational & visual math · Information theory & signal processing · Quantum physics
Subtitles (excerpt)
[Submit subtitle corrections at criblate.com] You've probably heard of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle from quantum mechanics, that the more you know about a particle's position, the less certain you can be of its momentum and vice versa. My goal here is for you to come away from this video feeling like this is utterly reasonable. It'll take some time, but I think you'll agree that digging deep is well worth it. You see, the uncertainty principle is actually one specific example of a much more general trade-off that shows up in a lot of everyday totally non-quantum circumstances involving waves. The plan here is to see what this means in the context of sound waves, which should feel reasonable, and then Doppler radar, which should again feel reasonable and a little bit closer to the quantum case, and then for particles, which if you're willing to accept one or two premises of quantum mechanics, hopefully feels just as reasonable as the first two. The core idea here has to do with the interplay between frequency and duration, and I bet you already have an intuitive idea of this principle before we even get into the math or the quantum. If you were to pull up behind a car at a red light,
On Hacker News
The clearest, most intuitive explanation of the Fourier Uncertainty Principle that I have come across is by Grant Sanderson of 3Blue1Brown. [VIDEO] — Cadwhisker, 2024-09
The reason Trek has it is likely a common misunderstanding of QM: it's not only that we cannot record both position and momentum, the information does not exist in the first place . It's easier to see why if you think about Fourier transforms: [VIDEO] TLDW: an infinitely long wave does not (cannot) have any definite location, but it does have a definite periodic wavelength; conversely, a single i… — ben_w, 2025-08
Yes, but that's because the momentum is the fourier transform of the position and vice versa So there's an uncertainty principle for signal processing, entirely because of the fourier transform and not because of quantum mechanics See this video [VIDEO] — nextaccountic, 2023-12
This may help answer some of your question, though I recognize it does not address it directly: [VIDEO] (3b1b on the Heisenberg uncertainty principle and how it arises) Think of a free neutron as the wave envelope, rather than any of the bumps in the wave. — uoaei, 2021-01
In many cases, Wikipedia actually lists the analogy for classical probability theory. For several theorems, the proof for Hilbert spaces can be directly brought to the classical world. The main difference to keep in mind is that we have amplitudes, not probabilities, and they can be negative or complex. We recover typical probability theory by taking norms/squares of amplitudes. The uncertainty p… — Kednicma, 2020-06
Related videos
- A new way to visualize General Relativity · ScienceClic English · 11:33
- Gender Neutral Pronouns: They're Here, Get Used To Them · Tom Scott · 3:48
- BlueHat IL 2019 - Andrew "bunnie" Huang - Supply Chain Security: "If I were a Nation State...” · Microsoft Israel R&D Center · 45:37
- But what is the Fourier Transform? A visual introduction. · 3Blue1Brown · 19:41
- Cybersecurity as Realpolitik by Dan Geer presented at Black Hat USA 2014 · Black Hat · 54:35
- Mark Blyth ─ Global Trumpism · Watson School of International and Public Affairs · 1:26:03
- Chernobyl 3828 · TeleconStudio · 26:57
- Flat Earth: A Measured Response · hbomberguy · 45:17
- TasBlock at AGDQ 2017: TASBot · TASVideosChannel · 58:44
- George Lakoff: Moral Politics · University of California Television (UCTV) · 58:57
- Tom Lehrer - Wernher von Braun · The Tom Lehrer Wisdom Channel · 1:46
- Congressional Fundraising: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO) · LastWeekTonight · 21:25
- DCEmu Reviews - 27C3 - Chaos Communication Congress 2010 - fail0verflow - FULL VIDEO · 1KIND Reviews · 44:39
- They're Made Out of Meat · niccollsdp · 6:16
- Hovering a Helicopter is Hilariously Hard - Smarter Every Day 145 · SmarterEveryDay · 9:45
- Data | Philosophy Tube · Philosophy Tube · 26:14
- The Alt-Right Playbook: Control the Conversation · Innuendo Studios · 10:47
- Super Mario World -- Credits Warp in 5:59.6 (First Time Ever on Console) · SethBling · 9:00
- Deadly Truth of General AI? - Computerphile · Computerphile · 8:30
- Velocity NY 2013: Richard Cook, "Resilience In Complex Adaptive Systems" · O'Reilly · 19:09