"We Really Don't Know How to Compute!" - Gerald Sussman (2011)

Channel:Strange Loop Conference · Length:1:04:18 · Published:2021-03-16 · Views:95870

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Gerald Sussman's 2011 Strange Loop keynote argues we still do not know how to compute, comparing biological systems with how we program machines. It touches on propagators, constraint programming and robustness.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters recommend it as a mind-expanding talk on rethinking programming, and cite it in threads on propagators, constraints and brittleness.

it made me question my views on what I think programming is — HN, 2023

Functional programming · Tech pioneers & interviews · Biology & biotechnology

Subtitles (excerpt)

hi what i'm going to tell you about today is that i actually think we're in real trouble that is i think we actually have the foggiest idea how to compute very well and i think that there are some small you know glimmer of hope on the horizon in a number of different directions which i may point out okay but i think most of the things we've been talking about even here are obsolete i thought what i said to uh somebody after the haskell session i went to there was a workshop yesterday is gee this is the most advanced of the obsolete languages okay and what i mean is this okay see that you now see the triangle that isn't there right everybody see the triangle that isn't there good okay what did you do it took only 100 milliseconds or maybe 200 milliseconds okay that means between your eyes and whatever it is that knew it was 100 milliseconds certainly if you had to put on brakes if you saw something like that right and it was crossing the street okay you know you know that's only if you had to build that's only a few tens of neuron times i don't care how parallel the machine is i have the foggiest idea how to write a program that organizes a complex process like that in a latency of about 30 or

On Hacker News

Grandparent is onto something. You can't define correctness without a spec. And since most business-oriented software, which most of us work with, isn't made against a comprehensive spec, you can argue that anything falling outside it is either a bug or a feature. 'If your disk backup software corrupts backups' has behind it a clean definition that's (pretty) unambiguous and you don't care about,… — gobdovan, 2026-06
I highly recommend Prof. Sussman talk at the Strange Loop conference 2011 [1]. It's not his inaugural lecture but it's pretty close where he talk about his research work with his former students. It's also paved the way to modern constraint programming based on logic and optimization which are the machine intelligence that's complementary to the conventional data driven and learning bases AI. [1]… — teleforce, 2025-04
For some reason programming is not getting any easier, I can even make an argument its getting worse despite all the improved tooling and andragogy investments we have done. Programming is in some sort of local minimum and we keep going in circles. Few years ago I watched this talk by Gerald Sussman: "We really don't know how to compute" - [VIDEO] and it made me question my views on what I think … — throwaway71271, 2023-09
you might be interested in [VIDEO] "We Really Don't Know How to Compute!"- Gerald Sussman (2011) [1:04:18] — pvillano, 2023-02
Not writing, but I have found all of Brett Victor's speeches to be incredibly inspiring on how I think about what I want to work on and where we're going. Inventing on Principle by Brett Victor: [LINK] Growing a Language by Guy Steele: [LINK] We Really Don't Know How to Compute! by Gerald Sussman: [VIDEO] — pfarrell, 2022-11

Related videos