The Alt-Right Playbook: Control the Conversation

Channel:Innuendo Studios · Length:10:47 · Published:2017-10-11 · Views:1465375

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Innuendo Studios' video from the Alt-Right Playbook series on how bad-faith actors control the conversation through debate tactics and moving goalposts.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends the series for explaining the tactics and mentality of bad-faith online arguments.

I found it enormously helpful to understand the mentality and tactics of a group that kind of doesn't make any sense. — HN, 2021

US politics & elections · Free speech, censorship & civil liberties · Media, journalism & propaganda

Subtitles (excerpt)

say for the sake of argument there's this guy who's running for president it's late in the campaign and one of his chief liabilities as a candidate is that over a dozen women have reported that he sexually assaulted them among them his ex-wife and a 13 year old girl his candidacy depends on convincing enough of the voting public that these accusations are false but then shortly before the election audio leaks of this guy backstage on TV and unaware his mic was on not just admitting to but bragging about kissing and groping women without their consent so the first question is how is he gonna spin that and the answer comes in the form of an Internet apology video where he begins with something like I don't know I never said I was a perfect person or claimed to be someone that I'm not at which point you pause the video like dude yes you have you have done literally both of those things so you pop on over to Twitter and comment on how this guy's apology opens with two comically untrue statements and like flies to manure his supporters show up in your mentions and they say that audio is from years ago what he means is he doesn't speak that way about women anymore to which you point out yes he does he did like two months ago and they

On Hacker News

Before this gets too far I’d just like to point out that anyone arguing this is an issue of free speech or “first they came for x, who’s next” is not arguing in good faith.. I’ve noticed a pattern of moving the goal post. The problem here is an insurrection and the loss of 5 American lives. Arguing there is not advantageous, easy, or particularly strong so the goal post moves to free speech leavi… — LimaBearz, 2021-01
A channel called Innuendo Studios chronicles this tactic and many others in a series called The Alt-Right Playbook [1]. I found it enormously helpful to understand the mentality and tactics of a group that kind of doesn't make any sense. [1] The Alt-Right Playbook: Control the Conversation - [VIDEO] — vladTheInhaler, 2021-01
The alt-right playbook ( [VIDEO] ) is a great summary of common experiences with this sort of cancer online. It's next to impossible to engage with these people for rational debate, when all they care about is spreading their hatred and ignorance through the virality of the internet, rendering pointless any civil discussion by arguing in bad faith. — che_shirecat, 2018-08
The problem is you're implicitly assuming this (and other recent "culture war topics" is actually about reasoning and legitimate attempt at debate. It isn't. This is about controlling narratives and reframing offensive goals so they become a legitimate political opinion. Most of these calls for a "debate" are not trying to actually debate anything. They are trying to make enough confusing noise a… — pdkl95, 2017-11
> Agenda setting power > platform power The Alt-Right Playbook feels like a bummer version of XKCD for these discussions: [Control the Conversation]( [VIDEO] ) — phatskat, 2025-07

Related videos