J.K. Rowling | ContraPoints

Channel:ContraPoints · Length:1:29:45 · Published:2021-01-26 · Views:7880546

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A roughly 90-minute video essay by ContraPoints on J.K. Rowling and the controversy around her views on gender. It examines why many LGBTQ people and allies soured on her.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends it as a thorough, nuanced perspective on the Rowling controversy and on cancel culture from a trans creator.

This is a good, calm, nuanced discussion about why LGBTQ people and our allies don't like Rowling as much as we used to. — HN, 2022

Free speech, censorship & civil liberties · Social issues & culture · Media, journalism & propaganda

Subtitles (excerpt)

- Bubble, bubble toil and trouble. (suspenseful music) Fire burn and cauldron bubble! Something wicked this way comes! Magical deeds are afoot dear readers, magical darkness (fan thwoorps) a must. (laughs) (fan thwoorps) Joanne, I wanna talk to you Joanne! (fan thwoorps) What is it about Joannes? I can't catch a break from these people. So, now that 2020 is finally over, I think we can let the record conclusively show that it was a year whomst is bad. And on top of everything else that was going on truly the last thing we needed was the author of Harry Potter coming forward to announce there's two things she can't stand: bigotry, and the transgenders. Ow! Elderberry wand, turgid, with a core of... Icedragon. Lumos! Can we afford spells? Is that in the budget? Expecto Patreon! So you've probably heard by now about Joanne Rowling's transphobic tweets, unless you've been living under a rock, in which case get back under that rock sweetie, there is nothing good going on up here it's not worth it. Or maybe you heard that all Joanne did was say biological sex is real, and now crazy gender ideologues and transactivists are trying to silence her. This is cancel culture gone too far, this is a witch hunt.

On Hacker News

The Internet has the same incentive landscape as bathroom stall graffiti. That's why you're so mad, Robyn. This isn't a back-and-forth between two real people who mutually respect each other. If I was talking to Robyn in real life, over coffee, for 2 or 3 hours, we'd probably get something productive done. But online, it's a hit-and-run dumpster where the truth matters a little, and humor and pre… — ReactiveJelly, 2022-12
It's 90 minutes, but ContraPoints' videos are really great. Here's her perspective on J.K. Rowling: [VIDEO] — geraldalewis, 2021-10
> Rowling's views are not 'dated' (that's your opinion) They are. Bigotry is not static. It's a dynamic reaction to progress being made in the rest of society. Her views are not a reaction to fringe whackjobs on twitter screaming for some rights that the rest of society is not willing to give them. Her views are a reaction to changes in government policy that do not happen overnight, are themselv… — deanCommie, 2021-01
The argument "I haven't met a single..." is equally as strong as an unqualified "You are misinformed.", which I was responding to. Note that I asked for clarification :) Since I have you here, would you mind elaborating a bit more about your stance on "cancel culture"? I'll also elaborate a bit more on my stance. I think most people would agree that mobs by definition have no united agenda. It's … — benrbray, 2021-03
He is not talking about cancel culture. He is taking this very overloaded term as premise, as self-evident "fact" for the degeneration of academia and "the public discourse", to pave the way for injecting his super deep ideology about salvation by Love, Elon and Ayn Rand. I am not sure, if you are familiar with Joscha Bach, but he once said something about something, and people think he's super i… — monopoledance, 2021-02

Related videos