Simulating alternate voting systems

Channel:Primer · Length:14:03 · Published:2020-11-02 · Views:4484043

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Primer uses simulations to compare voting systems such as first-past-the-post, approval, ranked choice and others. It shows how each system behaves and can be manipulated, with links to further voting theory resources.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters link it to explain why plurality voting produces two-party systems and how ranked-choice voting suffers spoiler effects.

There are mathematical reasons for FPTP to result in two party systems. [0] explains it pretty well. — HN, 2020

Probability & game theory · US politics & elections

Subtitles (excerpt)

Here in the United States, and in many other places around the world, there are two dominant political parties, and it's not so good. The question is if everyone hates two-party systems, why are they so common? Well, one big reason is the voting system most of us use. So in this video, we're gonna simulate elections to see why plurality is so bad, and we'll also look at two better voting systems. (slow soft music) Okay, so here are the three voting systems we're gonna look at. First, there's plurality voting, where every voter votes for exactly one candidate. This is also called first past the post. I'm honestly not quite sure why it's called that, but apparently it's a reference to horseracing. Second, we have instant runoff voting, sometimes called ranked choice voting where each voter ranks the candidates from best to worst, and then those rankings are used to eliminate one candidate at a time. And finally, there's approval voting where each voter can vote for as many candidates as they want. Each of these systems will have a flaw and a voting strategy related to that flaw, and we'll fill those in as we go. These are all voting systems that choose one winner. There are also systems that select multiple winners

On Hacker News

> and then we promised to not game the system That's the key point. Unfortunately, all known voting systems can be gamed. Here's an interesting video that explains how they can be manipulated: [VIDEO] — awb, 2022-10
Let's see. Canada currently has 338 MPs and over 80% (!) of those (278) belong to one of two majority parties. So yes, in theory Canada has a multi party system. In practice this multi party system is severely damaged by the effects of the FPTP voting system. There are mathematical reasons for FPTP to result in two party systems. [0] explains it pretty well. There don't have to be deeper underlyi… — esarbe, 2020-12
A reminder to support approval voting, star voting, and proportional voting so we can end the 2 party system. [VIDEO] [LINK] — amavect, 2026-08
Yet another reminder that we need approval voting, or even STAR voting, for single-winner elections. [VIDEO] [LINK] [LINK] — amavect, 2026-04
>imo proof that ranked choice is absolutely needed Ranked choice still succumbs to a spoiler effect. [LINK] [VIDEO] Approval voting works better and simpler, and STAR voting works even better though with more complexity. [LINK] — amavect, 2026-03

Related videos