The Lighthill Debate (1973) - part 1 of 6

Channel:bilkable · Length:14:06 · Published:2010-09-11 · Views:12892

Watch on YouTube

Summary

First part of a six-part recording of the 1973 Lighthill debate on AI, where Sir James Lighthill's critical report on AI research was contested by figures including McCarthy and Michie.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended as a historical look at the AI winter debate and a demolition of the expert systems hype.

If you want to watch a demolition of it see the following video — HN, 2017

Machine learning & deep learning · AI & data (other) · Tech pioneers & interviews

Subtitles (excerpt)

Good evening and welcome to the Royal Institution. Tonight we're going to enter a world where some of the oldest visions that have stirred man's imagination blend into the latest achievements of his science. Tonight we're going to enter the world of robots. Robots like Shaky developed by the Stanford Research Institute. Shaky is controlled by a large computer. He's directed through a radio antenna. Through a television camera, he gets visual feedback from his environment. The box appears on the monitor screen. The computer analyzes the traces which appear on the visual display until it can interpret them as an object it recognizes. Shaky gets tactile feedback through his feelers. He's able to move boxes with his push bar. He's programmed to solve certain problems that can be contrived in his environment. To choose, say, an alternative route to a certain point when his way has been blocked. Shaki is unquestionably an ingenious product of computer science and engineering. But is he anything more? Is he the forerunner of startling developments which will endow machines with artificial intelligence, enable them to compete with and even outstrip the human brain? Robots like this one in Stanford University's computer science department are

On Hacker News

Well, there was this place called "The Turing Institute" which was in Glasgow. It was run by a very nice man called Don Michie. I met Don a handful of times, and he was extremely kind and generous to me. He worked at Bletchley Park and died aged 91 having hit a bridge at 120mph going the wrong way up the M11 at 2am sitting next to his wife who had defected to Russia thirty years before. Don was d… — sgt101, 2017-08
Haha, this is arguably the article in AI. Other landmark events in the field include the Dartmouth Conference, when John McCarthy named the field "Artificial Intelligence", defined the goals, and set out to achieve them, unfortunately it's not easy to point to a single paper on the subject, though do read the conference proposal, posted on HN recently [ [LINK] ]; then you have the Lighthill repor… — AndrewOMartin, 2016-08
Why do you have to start your comment by accusing me of moving the goal posts? I don't even like ball games. Why is it so hard to have a decent conversation on the internet? It's a serious concern and I stand by it. It's perfectly possible -it's even easy- to make algorithms, systems, programs, what have you, that can solve one problem, perform one task, and do nothing else. Hell, you can train a… — YeGoblynQueenne, 2021-07

Related videos