Silence U Part 2: What Has Yale Become? | We the Internet Documentary

Channel:We the Internet TV · Length:12:36 · Published:2017-03-22 · Views:413001

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short documentary on the 2015 Yale Halloween costume controversy and the confrontation with Nicholas Christakis. Filmmaker Rob Montz investigates campus free speech and the state of the university afterward.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in debates about campus culture, free speech and workplace diversity controversies as a window into a particular mindset.

There's a good short video here that explores what's been happening at Yale — HN, 2019

Free speech, censorship & civil liberties · Social issues & culture

Subtitles (excerpt)

[ROB] Welcome to Yale. This place, one of the most prestigious universities in the world, birthed what's probably the most famous clip of the campus free speech controversies. [ANNOUNCER] "Early last week, a student confronted a head of one of Yale's undergraduate residents..." [ANNOUNCER] This insufferable brat... [ANNOUNCER] You can't wear the Halloween costume you want... [ANNOUNCER] How much speech is too much? [ROB] I had a suspicion that the public backlash missed what that outburst really meant: that the fixation on free speech ignored a deeper, darker scandal afflicting Yale. So I went there, and I found my scandal. What do you really know about the place that produces the people that run our country? Halloween 2015. An administrative committee sends out an email urging students not to wear appropriative Halloween costumes, and outlining some extremely broad rules. Yale lecturer Erika Christakis pushes back. She worries about creeping censorship and notes that, 'the ability to tolerate offense' is a central feature of a free and open society. Her email prompts a...disproportionate response. (chanting and yelling) [STUDENT] So important to give students of color a chance to heal from all the pain that we've been experiencing this week.

On Hacker News

The issue of administrators who repeatedly side with students even in absurd situations seems to be slowly reaching awareness. There's a good short video here that explores what's been happening at Yale: [VIDEO] Trigger warning - it has clips of students attacking professors and acting in ways that are completely delusional. I found it almost physically hard to watch and from the comments, seems … — repolfx, 2019-04
This is an amazing discussion and it really needs to occur. What scares me is how much this conversation is being ruled by an angry emotive mob, at the expense of democracy and free speech. There is almost no fact in any of these comments. Why MUST we have 50% of male and female in any industry? Have you noticed how almost every media outlet ignores female dominated industries (such as veterinary… — rustynails77, 2017-08
"I don't think you should have the same rights as me because your sexuality/gender/class/religion is different" Quite the opposite. Typically safe space warriors are demanding that people have different rights in public based on their genetics, not the same rights. E.g. "You're a white man so shut up, I should have a special right to speak over you because of [XYZ]." Here are some examples: [VIDE… — Banthum, 2017-03

Related videos