Why Do Things Keep Evolving Into Crabs?

Channel:PBS Eons · Length:7:27 · Published:2020-10-28 · Views:10932403

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short PBS Eons episode on carcinization, the repeated independent evolution of crab-like bodies in unrelated crustaceans, and what makes that form so successful.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it as a clear, well-made treatment of convergent evolution and crabs.

Can't endorse their style of science journalism enough. — HN, 2022

Evolution & genetics · Animals & nature

Subtitles (excerpt)

Around 10 million years ago, off the coast of what’s now New Zealand, a spiny, leggy creature with claws cruised the Pacific Ocean looking for food. This creature was an ancient ancestor of modern day king crabs, known to scientists as Paralomis debodeorum. It had a round, spiky carapace and a body about the size of a baseball, but not much else is known about it. This fossil is the only one of its kind ever found. And, based on how modern king crabs live, scientists think that Paralomis probably lived in very deep, cold water. But, no matter how Paralomis spent its days, scientists agree that if you saw one today, you’d recognize it as a crab. But it wasn’t a crab—at least, not a “true crab.” Paralomis and its modern counterparts belong to an infraorder known as Anomura, a huge group of crustaceans that includes everything from the porcelain crab to the coconut crab. Am I the only who is really horrified by coconut….coconut crabs? Give me a minute. Anyway, none of those animals that we call crabs are actually crabs. They all evolved from crustaceans that were longer and had tails, with a body plan more like a shrimp or a lobster. And then, for some reason, these animals evolved into things that looked like crabs, independently, over and over again.

On Hacker News

Eons did a great piece on this recently: [VIDEO] One of the things I love about the way Eons cover topics is how they don't just focus on what we know, but also how we know, who figured things out, and what we got wrong along the way. Can't endorse their style of science journalism enough. — kjeetgill, 2022-06
Counterpoint: Alien life will probably look very similar to life on earth. If you look at evolution then countless species have evolved into something crab-like: [VIDEO] Turns out that their form is pretty good for survival. While biology can take on a myriad of forms, the competitive nature of life will weed out a lot of them. And since the rules for biochemistry are the same across the universe… — jcfrei, 2023-02
Funny this came out the same month as SciShow’s “Why does everything keep evolving into crabs?” Video: [VIDEO] — erulabs, 2021-06
I made a post 11 days ago ( [LINK] ) about a wikipeida page regarding things evolving into crabs. Then today I see this youtube video on trending ( [VIDEO] ) talking about this very same concept. This is a very niche subject so I am surprised by its relative frequent appearances. This thing has happened to me before, so I finally decided to look up what its called. — yeetman21, 2020-10

Related videos