The Alt-Right Playbook: Never Play Defense

Channel:Innuendo Studios · Length:12:16 · Published:2017-11-29 · Views:1950741

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Innuendo Studios' video essay in the Alt-Right Playbook series argues that bad-faith actors force opponents to defend their positions, so the way to avoid their trap is to never play defense.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it when arguing that debating bad-faith arguers hands them the framing and exposure.

See "Never Play Defense" from the alt-right playbook — HN, 2023

US politics & elections · Social issues & culture · Media, journalism & propaganda

Subtitles (excerpt)

There's this feminist media critic whose work you respect. Being an internet savvy human in the information age you sometimes share your opinions of her work on your various social media platforms. And you've noticed whenever you speak positively of her, many different people come out to yell the same handful of things at you. It usually starts with: And you say: And they say: And you say: And they say: And you say: Now by this time you've noticed your interlocutor's position has changed from As though these are all the same argument. And you also notice the pattern of the conversation. He says something short quippy and wrong, you give a detailed correction, he says something else short, quippy, wrong, and only tangentially related to his last point, and the cycle repeats itself. This goes on and on. And it's not, you've noticed, just this discussion. You find this manner of argument often when you express left of centre beliefs. You talk about the election, someone says you vote democrat because you must have a conservative father you hate. You talk about polyamory, someone says if you have more than one female partner you must be a sexist. Or they just say you're faking a non regional accent

On Hacker News

Could we say that biologically/culturally receptive to performed dominance and being dominant has nothing to do with rationally understand the world. I think this is the whole point of the jock/geek binary opposition in culture even though, as all oppositionnal pairs in culture, they are often porquenolosdossed : Some people can perform dominance and do master rationality quite well and some can … — cassepipe, 2024-07
Alas, it seems that in practice humans are often motivated by something "short, quippy, and wrong" [0] over something with more details like demarcating areas of ambiguity. So the "better" sources have an uphill fight to be influential. [0] [VIDEO] — Terr_, 2023-11
This seems very naive to me. There are enough people yelling "OK Groomer" at me on certain platforms that I know the signal to noise ratio is bad enough that engaging is at best a waste of time and at worst throwing more soundbites than I can debunk or bystanders can dead so I lose the debate (for any bystander) by default. See "Never Play Defense" from the alt-right playbook: [VIDEO] And as an a… — asmor, 2023-06
Isn't it funny how things like this are never written by the boring types? It's always those wild, maverick, enlightened types seeking to describe themselves and, along the way, describe others, but mostly to describe themselves in flattering terms, with just a light veneer of modesty. (The self-assessed MBTI INTJs are just fantastically entertaining at this.) "All great ideas come from us," beam… — thaumaturgy, 2020-07
> All these tools for "taking control of the narrative" will be used by your enemies. The alt-right already takes control of the narrative. [VIDEO] Even if this platform ever "took off" enough to be used by bad people, the only thing that would happen is we'd have a level playing field. — some_furry, 2020-04

Related videos