Feynman: Magnets FUN TO IMAGINE 4 But see NEW UPDATED file at https://tinyurl.com/ycphc432
Channel:Christopher Sykes · Length:7:32 · Published:2008-12-28 · Views:1571431
Summary
A clip from the BBC Fun to Imagine series in which Richard Feynman is asked how magnets work and explains why 'why' questions depend on a shared framework of understanding and cannot always be answered in layman's terms.
Why HN recommends it
Cited constantly when discussing explaining to non-experts, the limits of explanation and what a 'why' question really asks.
mhartl has already posted this excellent video — HN, 2010
Fundamental physics · Scientific method & science communication
Subtitles (excerpt)
Magnesy [reporter] Jeśli weźmiesz dwa magnesy I zbliżysz je do siebie, możesz poczuć jak się odpychają Odwróć magnesy stronami i się złączą. Tak więc.. czym jest to odczucie, pomiędzy magnesami? [Feynman] Co masz na myśli mówiąc odczucie pomiędzy magnesami? [ reporter ] Cóż, coś tam jest, nieprawdaż? [reporter] mam na myśli, że.. odnoszę wrażenie, że coś tam jest [pomiędzy magnesami] kiedy je do siebie zbliżam Posłuchaj, o co spytałem. Co masz na myśli mówiąc "odczucie" Jasne, że coś odczuwasz. Pytanie tylko, czego chcesz się dowiedzieć Chcę się dowiedzieć co się tam dzieje. [Feynman] Magnesy się odpycha.. Pomiędzy magne.. pomiędzy tymi dwoma kawałkami metalu [ Feynman ] Magnesy się odpychają [reporter] no cóż, ale w takim razie co to znaczy?Dlaczego one to robią?Albo jak to robią? [Feynman] Hm. Pytasz.. [reporter] Wybacz, ale uważam, że to rozsądne pytanie [Feynman] Jasne, że to rozsądne pytanie. To doskonałe pytanie! Niestety problem, który.. o który pytasz Widzisz, kiedy pytasz "dlaczego coś się dzieje" Jak można odpowiedzieć na pytanie "dlaczego coś się dzieje" Na przykład.. Ciocia Many / Mandy (?) jest w szpitalu.. Dlaczego? Bo się poślizgnęła na lodzie i złamała biodro. Taka odpowiedź zadowala.. ludzi.
On Hacker News
Of anyone I've read or seen (in person or from videos), Feynman has the best fundamental grasp of meta-knowledge. By meta-knowledge, for lack of a better term, I mean understanding what it means to know something. mhartl has already posted this excellent video: [VIDEO] , where he explains what the word "why" means in scientific inquiry. When we answer a "why" question, we don't really explain a c… — DevX101, 2010-11
Sometimes it's not always possible to explain something in sufficient detail to someone who has no concept of what you are trying to explain. Feynman explains this really well when trying to answer a question about magnets: "Of course, it's an excellent question. But the problem, you see, when you ask why something happens, how does a person answer why something happens? For example, Aunt Minnie … — jliechti1, 2014-01
For those who think this doesn't sound at least a little bit like Feynman, I highly recommend this video: [VIDEO] — mhartl, 2010-11
This Feynman quote from the article is put in the wrong context: > I really can’t do a good job, any job, of explaining magnetic force in terms of something else you’re more familiar with, because I don’t understand it in terms of anything else you’re more familiar with. The article implies this is a case of the scientist expressing that he didn't understand a thing. But watching the video in ful… — jancsika, 2017-06
Like Feynman said in this video [VIDEO] , when trying to explain how magnate works to the reporter. I think it's hard for someone else to actually understand the problem when you two are not in the same knowledge framework. Cause then she/he will be perpetually asking the why and how question and being not satisfied. edited. — fatman13gg, 2016-08
Related videos
- George Carlin - Euphemisms · poyani · 9:01
- TWiST #46 with David Heinemeier Hansson · ThisWeekinStartups · 1:57:11
- Crockford on JavaScript - Volume 1: The Early Years · YUI Library · 1:42:08
- The Quantum Conspiracy: What Popularizers of QM Don't Want You to Know · Google TechTalks · 1:03:43
- James Burke Connections, Ep. 1 "The Trigger Effect" · DRS_Education · 49:22
- Hamming, "You and Your Research" (June 6, 1995) · securitylectures · 44:02
- Why Being Delusional is a Superpower · Veritasium · 12:04
- Is Most Published Research Wrong? · Veritasium · 12:22
- Richard Feynman Fire · nebulajr · 4:43
- I bought 1000 meters of wire to settle a physics debate · AlphaPhoenix · 22:48
- Powers of Ten™ (1977) · Eames Office · 9:01
- The Speed of Light is NOT About Light · PBS Space Time · 12:46
- Feynman on Scientific Method. · seabala · 9:59
- Why No One Has Measured The Speed Of Light · Veritasium · 19:05
- Why It Was Almost Impossible to Make the Blue LED · Veritasium · 33:44
- Richard Feynman - The.Character of Physical Law - Part 1 The Law of Gravitation (full version) · Tinkerin' Thinkers · 56:04