The Trains that Subsidize Suburbia - GO Transit Commuter Rail

Channel:Not Just Bikes · Length:15:49 · Published:2021-09-27 · Views:1351937

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Not Just Bikes examines Toronto's GO Transit commuter rail, arguing it is a costly system with park-and-ride stations and rush-hour-only service that subsidizes car-dependent suburbs.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in transit debates to show the cost and low utilization of commuter rail and the case for dense housing around stations.

explored more on the NotJustBikes YouTube Channel — HN, 2023

Transit, cities & urban planning

Subtitles (excerpt)

In the previous video, we talked about VIA Rail, the intercity train service in Canada, and why it’s really hard to justify taking the train instead of driving. I took VIA rail again this summer, and though they didn’t ask me to weigh my bags, they do have a check-in process now. One step closer to making train travel as painful as airline travel. And due to corona restrictions, the 7 trains per day from London to Toronto has been reduced to 3 trains per day. Did you miss your train to Toronto? That’s OK, there’s another one coming … in 9 hours. But enough about VIA Rail. In this video, I want to talk about the least-terrible heavy rail trains in Canada: GO Transit. GO Transit is a commuter rail service, run by the Government of Ontario. G.O. GO. Get it? It’s right there in the name. These days, the infrastructure and trains are managed by Metrolinx, the government agency responsible for regional travel in the greater Toronto Area. GO also operates a network of buses, but these run on regular roads and routinely get stuck in traffic so they’re really not that interesting. Let’s talk about trains! As a rider, taking the GO train is quite nice. The stations are clean and well maintained,

On Hacker News

There are several talking points mentioned in this thread that are explored more on the NotJustBikes YouTube Channel. - When Canada built a relatively recent urban rail to Toronto, they built it so you have to drive to the train station , and used the high value land right around the station for ... surface car parking. This is absurdly wasteful of valuable real estate and makes the expensive tra… — jodrellblank, 2023-08
Building giant parking garages ("commuting park and ride") is a failed concept and does not work. No one wants to live around a giant parking area and no one will walk through it to get to the train because there's no housing density nearby. Better to build high density housing around the station with little parking. [VIDEO] — mperham, 2023-05
> The more you add road capacity, the less 'demand is induced', because there's limited amount of people. And how much money would it cost to build out enough road infrastructure to 'overwhelm all possible demand'? How much would it cost to move the same amount of people via some other form of transportation? The province of Ontario finds it cheaper to run an entire railway (GO Transit) compared … — throw0101a, 2022-04
Somewhat tangentially, I watched a recent Not Just Bikes YouTube video that discusses the merits of commuter rail [1]. The video is obviously trying to discourage infrastructure that supports car-based suburbs, but another point came out that struck me: commuter rail is very expensive infrastructure with very low utilization, say 4 incoming trains in the morning and 4 outgoing trains in the eveni… — kumarsw, 2021-11

Related videos