QI | No Such Thing As A Fish
Channel:QI · Length:2:36 · Published:2014-06-11 · Views:2415712
Summary
A short clip from the British panel show QI in which the panel discusses why there is no such thing as a fish as a biological category.
Why HN recommends it
Linked in threads about fuzzy categories, such as fish, trees and fruit, as the origin of the phrase and a fun illustration.
I like this clip from a QI episode where they discuss if there is such a thing called as fish — HN, 2020
Animals & nature · Stand-up & sketch comedy
Subtitles (excerpt)
What conclusion did the great biologist, Stephen J. Gould, draw from a lifetime study of fish? Oh. Yeah. They haven't got any legs. Is that Is that his lifetime study? What was his lifetime study of a fish? After a while, they smell. He was a bit sick and he just stared at it and they haven't got any legs. Starfish Starfish don't have brains. It's the kind of Louis Walsh of the aquatic world. They really don't have brains, the starfish. And they're not really fish, are they, starfish, to be honest? Well, the word fish is in there, which kind of qualifies them, I think. Well, is a starfish a fish? Is a jellyfish a fish? Well, yeah. a fish? Yes, I believe so. But the starfish There's a division, isn't there, in the world whether it should be down to sort of uh experts in biology whether things are fish or or whether it should be down to menus. Yes. See, I think for example, a crayfish comes under fish in a menu. He looks like he's reading the soul by day on the train. Stephen J. Gould was a very great He's dead now. He's very a very great He won a Nobel Prize. He was a paleontologist and an extraordinary biologist. And uh he came to a conclusion which is They can feel no love. No, that they that there is no such thing as a fish.
On Hacker News
I like this clip from a QI episode where they discuss if there is such a thing called as fish (as per Stephen Jay Gould) Particularly like David Mitchell and Sean Lock (or as a comment spells his last name Locke) [VIDEO] — atulatul, 2020-09
In addition to the sibling comments, I'd point out that the article is sort of an extended riff on the phrase, "There is no such thing as a fish," which was a sloppy QI paraphrase [0][1] of a principle elucidated by the 20th century paleontologist Stephen Jay Gould, and later became the title of QI's well-known podcast [2]. And of course, fish do exist, just not in the simplistic way that many of… — zuminator, 2021-12
> It's somewhat illuminating to learn that all abstractions are leaky You appear to be presenting these ideas as though they would be new to me, which they aren't. In fact, these ideas are essentially pop-science[0]. Incidentally, the rhetoric you are employing is also used by Flat Earthers[1], so well done for that, I suppose. > For example, you can't reliably represent "sex" using a "bit" type … — yakshaving_jgt, 2021-12
I think you are right. Vegetable has only a culinary definition, not a botanical one. And I don't think many people would classify watermelons as a vegetable, except that watermelon skins are sometimes used for cooking. On the other hand, watermelons are definitely fruits, in both the botanical and culinary sense. This is reminds me of this video: [No Such Thing As A Fish]( [VIDEO] ) — powersnail, 2021-11
Related videos
- Harder Drive: Hard drives we didn't want or need · suckerpinch · 36:46
- Dick Proenneke in Alone in the Wilderness · swererbob · 9:33
- Jackie Chan - How to Do Action Comedy · Every Frame a Painting · 9:04
- DOUGLAS ADAMS: Parrots, the Universe and Everything · University of California Television (UCTV) · 1:27:36
- George Carlin Talks About "Stuff" · CappyNJ · 5:09
- Captain Disillusion: World's Greatest Blenderer - Live at the Blender Conference 2018 · Captain Disillusion · 41:43
- The Intense 8 Hour Hunt | Attenborough Life of Mammals | BBC Earth · BBC Earth · 7:10
- Where in the world is it easiest to get rich? | Harald Eia | TEDxOslo · TEDx Talks · 15:41
- Happy People | Spring (part 1) [Happy People Documentary | Spring in Siberia Part 1 · Дмитрий Васюков · 53:55
- Patrick Stewart interview - Parkinson - BBC · BBC Studios · 4:45
- How Trees Bend the Laws of Physics · Veritasium · 7:22
- DAIRY IS SCARY! · Erin Janus · 5:40
- Man Spends 30 Years Turning Degraded Land into Massive Forest – Fools & Dreamers (Full Documentary) · Happen Films · 29:38
- John Cleese vs Extremism · eroosters · 2:12
- Worst Nuclear Accidents in History · Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell · 9:12
- It's Not About The Nail · Jason Headley · 1:41