DEFCON 20: Bigger Monster, Weaker Chains: The National Security Agency and the Constitution

Channel:Christiaan008 · Length:48:52 · Published:2012-11-18 · Views:10453

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A DEFCON 20 panel with NSA whistleblower William Binney, journalist James Bamford and ACLU lawyers on the NSA's mass collection of communications and its conflict with the Constitution.

Why HN recommends it

HN points to it as a prescient talk that discussed, in 2012, much of what Snowden's leaks later confirmed.

lot of the stuff which was later leaked by Snowden is discussed here — HN, 2015

Security & hacking · Privacy, surveillance & cybercrime · Free speech, censorship & civil liberties

Subtitles (excerpt)

I'm Jamal Jaffer I'm a lawyer for the ACLU and I'm up here with uh Bill Benny Alex obdo and Jim Bamford who I will introduce uh more fully in just a second um I'm not sure how many of you got a chance to hear uh Keith Alexander yesterday the head of the NSA uh talk about the nsa's activities uh I wasn't there myself but I I have heard that he offered a few reassurances um one of them apparently was that uh the NSA is not in fact keeping a file on every American um the I'm just reporting all right the the the second the second reassurance he offered is that when the NSA incidentally or inadvertently collects information about Americans uh it's required by law to minimize that information meaning it's required by law to Del it or to redact it and the third thing he said is that the nsa's activities and I think this is in some ways the most reassuring thing uh the nsa's activities are fully consistent with the Constitution and with the and with the foreign intelligence surveillance act which is the statute that governs the nsa's activities inside the United States so the question I want to ask is you know why why is it that that the head of the NSA feels obliged to to offer those kinds of reassurances right now

On Hacker News

A year before Snowden took off to Hong Kong, William Binney was on a panel at Def Con where NSA surveillance was talked about at length, worth a watch - [VIDEO] lot of the stuff which was later leaked by Snowden is discussed here, nice to see Binney vindicated. Interestingly, the NSA facility in Hawaii where Snowden was working at the time is mentioned by name. I often wonder if this Defcon talk … — jmkni, 2015-06
I remember the DefCon 20 talk, Bigger Monsters, Weaker Chains with William Binney - [VIDEO] This was in 2012, 2013 was when Snowden did what he did. I always wondered if he saw this talk and was motivated by it. — jmkni, 2019-09
The NSA is wholesale collecting data and later using a secret court to authorize them to query their own databases [1]. PRISM is not just an interface. It is officially known as SIGAD US-984XN which means it intercepts and collects electronic communications. [1] Bamford, Binney and the ACLU at Defcon 2012 [VIDEO] — dram, 2013-06
The Defcon video is similar: [VIDEO] (not sure if this link is bootleg) [LINK] (just the audio) has the ACLU and the same guy if that makes it more legit. The 10 zetabyte storage capacity estimate is based on building size. I think we need more details. — saber_taylor, 2012-12

Related videos