Murray Gell-Mann talks about Richard Feynman

Channel:Muon Ray · Length:5:30 · Published:2012-01-13 · Views:254052

Watch on YouTube

Summary

In a short interview clip, physicist Murray Gell-Mann talks about working alongside Richard Feynman at Caltech. He describes how the two men clashed in personality and image despite similar brilliance.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters cite it for Gell-Mann's candid and not always flattering view of Feynman's showmanship and character.

Here is what Murray Gell-Mann has to say about this side of Feynman's personality — HN, 2013

Tech pioneers & interviews · Fundamental physics

Subtitles (excerpt)

Oh, well I was attracted by the idea that Dick Fineman and I would collaborate on things and we did for a number of years. Yes, he was there. He in fact invited me to Caltech. He uh he persuaded the department to uh hire me. He uh he was quite impressed with some of the pieces of work that I had uh done. One was the uh what's now called the reormalization group work with Francis Low. uh which we carried out at the hot summer at the University of Illinois. Uh and Dick said that was that this was the only piece of work on quantum electronamics uh that he'd ever seen that he hadn't any inkling of. and he got quite excited about it and actually extended the results a little bit. It also revealed some errors in a number of calculations that people had made because uh we had we had a we knew what certain fourth order terms looked like in the expansion of quantum electronamics and some of the papers didn't get them right. Uh but anyway we did work together for few years and it was very pleasant. It was very exciting. We uh would bounce ideas off each other and call each other at odd times of day and night and uh try things and then find they didn't work and then try other things and find they did work and so on.

On Hacker News

>Being humble in the search for truth can sometimes even seem arrogant socially. It means that you'll regularly question not only your own beliefs but those of other people as well. Although according to Murray Gell-Mann, Feynman might have gone a bit too far in that regard [VIDEO] — dralley, 2022-02
From Murray Gell-Mann: [VIDEO] Several clips from Gell-Mann's Web of Stories interview (late 1990s) pertain to his on-again off-again collaboration with Feynman. [LINK] — OldGuyInTheClub, 2020-02
None of those quotes are derogatory toward Feynman, and I don't see how Wolfram being pleased by Feynman liking his idea says anything about Wolframs ego. In fact, this was very modest for Wolfram standards, and a much more interesting and cultured homage to a friend, than the ones by Susskind or Gell-Mann: [LINK] [VIDEO] I must say I in general don't understand the hate a lot of people have for … — stiff, 2014-01
> Seems not everyone was a fan of Mr. Feynman Oh. Many people didn't really like him (in spite of acknowledging his ability). For example, Murray Gell-Mann - [VIDEO] — shadowfox, 2014-01
Feynman was a bit of a hipster. I am a fan of his, being a theoretical physicist by training and having read more than one book by him and about him, but to tell the truth nobody is perfect and Feynman's showmanship was at times considered cheap and annoying by some of his friends and collaborators. Here is what Murray Gell-Mann has to say about this side of Feynman's personality: [VIDEO] — emini_guy, 2013-05

Related videos