The Russian Grab | Peter Zeihan

Channel:Speakers Spotlight · Length:3:35 · Published:2017-04-21 · Views:269468

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A four-minute 2017 clip of geopolitical analyst Peter Zeihan discussing a Russian land grab, in which he anticipated a Russian move on Ukraine.

Why HN recommends it

Cited after the 2022 invasion as evidence Zeihan predicted the Ukraine war years earlier.

Here is a three minute snippet from one of his talks from five years ago — HN, 2022

Geopolitics & foreign policy

Subtitles (excerpt)

Russians are the flavor of the month. They're being a little pnikity. Let's talk about why they're dying out, too. Two particular problems are on the short-term forecast for the Russians. First things first, here's your draftable age at age 18 to 20. In five years, the number of potential drafties will drop by half. The Red Army with half the size it has is not a military threat to most of the countries that are around it. So if the Russians are going to use military force to achieve what they want, they have to do it now. Second, the average age of male mortality is 59. The Russian technical educational system collapsed back in 1989, which means that the youngest cadre of Russian engineers who have the full suite of technical training are now in their 50s. In five years, they're going to start dying in mass. And the Russians won't be able to maintain their infrastructure, their missile forces, their army, their electricity system. So if they're going to move, they have to move now. And here's where they're moving. This is Eurasia on its side, north at the top or north on the right side, the green area. If you have to live in Russia, that's where you want to live. It's not too cold. I mean, it's still cold, but uh you can live here.

On Hacker News

Peter Zeihan had an interesting take on this, that the Russians moved on Ukraine because their demographic decline means that if they don't invade now, they will forever lose the ability to wage war and hence defend their homeland. The Soviet-era population is rapidly aging out of military service age, and the post-Soviet generation is tiny, and so they will not be able to field a meaningful army… — nostrademons, 2023-06
> It isn't the Stratfor origin, or the blazenly pro-American optimism per se that concern me Are you sure about that? Because all you've written is that Zeihan, who focuses on practical and immediate concerns of demographics, energy and agricultural markets - is obfuscating realities and monopolizing ears. Eh? As opposed to what or whom? Here is a three minute snippet from one of his talks from f… — recuter, 2022-11
Reiterating from memory of his lectures on YouTube: - The Russians consider some nine-odd geographic boundaries of the former union to be crucial to defense (e.g. between mountains and deserts, certain ports). Without fortifying there, a lot of the Rus land area is open and hard to defend. Interestingly, Ukraine contains only one in Crimea (which they already had) but is on the way to ones in Rom… — maxvu, 2022-07
Here’s one for you: He predicted the invasion of Ukraine back in this video from 2017 (actually earlier, but this was the easiest source for me to cite): [VIDEO] The whole video is pretty short, but he mentions Ukraine about 2 1/2 minutes in. — MR4D, 2022-06

Related videos