Why 90% of Managers Are GARBAGE (The Professional Lie) | Steve Jobs

Channel:Evan Carmichael · Length:3:54 · Published:2015-03-01 · Views:4612140

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short clip of Steve Jobs arguing that the best people are self-managing and that professional managers who cannot do the work add little. He says leadership is about a shared vision.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in threads on management, hiring and company culture for Jobs's views on self-managing people and small, self-policing core teams.

My favorite Steve Job's video on the subject — HN, 2018

Tech pioneers & interviews · Management, leadership & organizations

Subtitles (excerpt)

The greatest people are self-managing. They don’t need to be managed. If they know-- Once they know what to do, they’ll go figure out how to do it, and they don’t need to be managed at all. What they need is a common vision, and that’s what leadership is. What leadership is having a vision, being able to articulate that so the people around you can understand it, and getting a consensus on a common vision. We wanted people that were insanely great at what they did, but were not necessarily those seasoned professionals, but who had at the tips of their fingers and in their passion the latest understanding of where technology was and what we could do with that technology, and we wanted to bring that to lots of people. So the neatest thing that happens is when you get a core group of, you know, ten great people, it becomes self-policing as to who they let into that group. So I consider the most important job of someone like myself is recruiting. We agonized over hiring. We had interviews. I'd go back and look at some of the interviews again. They would start at 9:00 or 10:00 in the morning and go through dinner. A new interviewee would talk to everybody in the building at least once and maybe a couple times, and then come back for another round of interviews,

On Hacker News

Completely in agreement. Hire a bad leader when the company is growing and you risk one year later to have the whole company infested by all sort of people that you would not like to have around (managers included). Some companies completely screw up themselves because of this. Startups usually do not think about this early enough and when the founders realize what is going on is too late and the… — ChrisCinelli, 2018-12
Steve Job's view on management shares similarities to what you have described and I think from my experience I agree with this outlook [VIDEO] "The greatest people are self managing, they don't need to be managed. Once they know what to do they will figure out how to do it. What they need is a common vision, and that's what leadership is. Leadership is having a vision, being able to articulate th… — mentos, 2017-12
"The neatest thing that happens is, when you get a core croup of ten people, it becomes self policing, as to who they let into that group." —Steve Jobs [VIDEO] — andai, 2025-10
Steve Jobs on a related topic, what it means to be a leader: [VIDEO] Guess VPs (according to both) are it — gsf_emergency_2, 2025-03
I hate to be that guy, but I believe that many line managers & middle managers aren't honestly needed in knowledge work at a certain level of self-managing ICs with a common vision. It's increasingly rare to find "good" managers among the bad. The good ones tend to find new jobs or get promoted and continue to climb the ladder. The bad ones? They also get promotions to take over the good ones job… — thenerdhead, 2022-03

Related videos