Why Democracy Is Mathematically Impossible
Channel:Veritasium · Length:23:34 · Published:2024-08-27 · Views:10142097
Summary
Veritasium explains why no voting system can be perfectly fair, drawing on Arrow's theorem and the work of Eric Maskin. It looks at problems with systems like first-past-the-post and ranked-choice voting.
Why HN recommends it
Linked when someone needs a quick accessible source for the claim that every voting method has flaws.
most voting systems are mathematically unfair [0] — HN, 2025
Pure mathematics · Probability & game theory · US politics & elections
Subtitles (excerpt)
- Democracy might be mathematically impossible. (serious music) This isn't a value judgment, a comment about human nature, nor a statement about how rare and unstable democratic societies have been in the history of civilization. Our current attempt at democracy, the methods we're using to elect our leaders, are fundamentally irrational. And this is a well-established mathematical fact. This is a video about the math that proved that fact and led to a Nobel Prize. It's a video about how groups of people make decisions and the pitfalls that our voting systems fall into. (subdued music) One of the simplest ways to hold an election is to ask the voters to mark one candidate as their favorite on a ballot. And when the votes are counted, the candidate with the most votes wins the election. This is known as "first past the post" voting. The name is kind of a misnomer though. There is no post that any of the candidates need to get past. The winner is just the candidate with the most votes. This method likely goes back to antiquity. It has been used to elect members of the House of Commons in England since the 14th century, and it's still a common voting system with 44 countries in the world using it
On Hacker News
There is actually extensive mathematical history to fair voting, the output of which is super not in use, and of which I do find plenty of the alternative systems more representative: [VIDEO] I do think regular variety elections are generally representative though. I just also see value in keeping these asterisks in mind. — perching_aix, 2026-04
Yeah. It's complicated. See Veritasium's "Why Democracy is Mathematically Impossible" [VIDEO] And also Idiocracy. This one is becoming more relevant. In all countries and all races. — alecco, 2025-12
FPTP is bad but other methods are similarly flawed: [VIDEO] Keeping a democracy requires people to understand it as well. At least in US it seems they'd rather elect a dictator wannabe who clearly said he wanted to be dictator for a day than elect a woman. — thisisit, 2025-09
> EU citizens voted for this. I'm growing pretty tired of this rhetoric / rhetorical sleight of hand, but maybe this is a reasonable opportunity to discuss it: - not all citizens of a jurisdiction are eligible for voting: in this case, cursory search suggests only 400M (88.8%) of 450M were eligible - seems a bit too high to me, but let's roll with it regardless - not all who are eligible actually… — perching_aix, 2025-07
I'm not so sure if putting down a vote for one candidate over many others every few years suffices as democracy though to begin with. [0] [0] [VIDEO] — perching_aix, 2025-05
Related videos
- Vectors | Chapter 1, Essence of linear algebra · 3Blue1Brown · 9:51
- But what is the Fourier Transform? A visual introduction. · 3Blue1Brown · 19:41
- George Lakoff: Moral Politics · University of California Television (UCTV) · 58:57
- Lec 1 | MIT 18.06 Linear Algebra, Spring 2005 · MIT OpenCourseWare · 39:49
- Why Electronic Voting Is Still A Bad Idea · Tom Scott · 12:00
- Republic, Lost | Lawrence Lessig | Talks at Google · Talks at Google · 57:19
- The Most IMPORTANT Video You'll Ever See (part 1 of 8) · wonderingmind42 · 9:17
- Antonin Scalia - On American Exceptionalism · AmericanRhetoric.com · 7:21
- The Cardboard Box Reform - Nixon's Ghost Bill & A Crucial Flaw in Democracy · CRI · 1:02:37
- The Coming Collapse of the Middle Class with Elizabeth Warren · University of California Television (UCTV) · 57:37
- Why Being Delusional is a Superpower · Veritasium · 12:04
- The essence of calculus · 3Blue1Brown · 17:04
- We the People, and the Republic we must reclaim | Lawrence Lessig · TED · 18:19
- Why Your Vote Doesn't Count · CGP Grey · 6:31
- Siggraph2019 Geometric Algebra · Bivector · 1:37:21
- Category Theory 1.1: Motivation and Philosophy · Bartosz Milewski · 46:46