We Are The Art | Brandon Sanderson’s Keynote Speech
Channel:Brandon Sanderson · Length:18:35 · Published:2026-01-30 · Views:585662
Summary
Brandon Sanderson's keynote on AI-generated art, arguing that the artistic process and the journey matter more than the finished product. He explains why he rebels against generative AI in creative work.
Why HN recommends it
HN commenters share it as an eloquent argument that AI output is not art, and as a companion to worries about losing deep thinking.
Here is author Brandon Sanderson eloquently explaining why AI generated slop will never be art — HN, 2026
LLMs & generative AI · AI safety, AGI & impact · Literature & writing craft
Subtitles (excerpt)
[applause] What has been on my mind lately? Some of you are going to be able to guess. In April 2010, film critic Roger Gert he made an infamous claim. He said, "Video games can never be art." Yeah, I know. I know. His uh blog post set off this firestorm of discussion. I was there back then on the internet. I'm old. And uh yeah, everyone was talking about it, talking about kind of how he's an outofouch old man yelling at clouds, maybe yelling at clouds that were actually shrubs. Mario joke. Um, some of you old-timers know that I disagree profoundly with Mr. Eert, but he was an intelligent, articulate scholar, and he had a better point than this clickbaity quote might imply. His army argument was this. games are about mechanics and winning, not about aesthetic enjoyment. So, if I'm going to summarize him too briefly, and he wrote a long blog post on this two years later, you can still look up on his website. I essentially said that while video games can contain art, such as an amazing digital painting, they are not at their core art because their focus is on obstacles to overcome in order to win. by being victory focused. He argued they were an innately commercial product like a toaster and not able to be
On Hacker News
Keep making music. Here is author Brandon Sanderson eloquently explaining why AI generated slop will never be art: [VIDEO] tl;dr: the final product is just a receipt of the effort, the sleepless nights, the self-doubt and personal transformation that goes into creating art. They have found a way to automate creating this receipt, without the personal transformation that an artist goes through, a … — sph, 2026-04
> The surge of AI, large language models, and generated art begs fascinating questions. The industry’s progress so far is enough to force us to explore what art is and why we make it. Brandon Sanderson explores the rise of AI art, the importance of the artistic process, and why he rebels against this new technological and artistic frontier. What It Means To Be Human | Art in the AI Era [VIDEO] — babblingfish, 2026-02
I have no idea who this guy is (I guess he's a fantasy novelist?) but this video came up in my YouTube feed recently and feels like it matches closely with the themes you're expressing. [VIDEO] — moron4hire, 2026-02
I used to have this feeling, and I just got over this hurdle. I now continue coding by hand with zero AI usage. It's amazing how much better you feel when you get to use your brain. What really helped me was many perspective shifts perspective shift 1: the people that never cared about programming/engineer finally left of the room. the people chasing the trends, trying to grift, or just after mon… — drudolph914, 2026-07
Related videos
- Rowan Atkinson on free speech · The Christian Institute · 9:25
- Ross's Game Dungeon: Deus Ex · Accursed Farms · 39:52
- "Programming a 144-computer chip to minimize power" - Chuck Moore (2013) · Strange Loop Conference · 40:12
- Positive Affirmations for Site Reliability Engineers · KRAZAM · 4:00
- Why Don't You Want To Do Anything After Binging 4 Hours of YouTube Videos... · HealthyGamerGG · 22:09
- Prof. Robert Lustig - 'Sugar, metabolic syndrome, and cancer' · Low Carb Down Under · 57:42
- Segmented Displays · Posy · 13:55
- "What UNIX Cost Us" - Benno Rice (LCA 2020) · linux.conf.au · 34:14
- Saifedean Ammous: Bitcoin, Anarchy, and Austrian Economics | Lex Fridman Podcast #284 · Lex Fridman · 4:14:40
- Stephen Fry on American vs British Comedy · anc6368 · 4:19
- DjangoCon 2008 Keynote: Cal Henderson · Google for Developers · 1:02:43
- Aphex Twin - T69 Collapse · Aphex Twin · 5:19
- The Soul of Erlang and Elixir • Sasa Juric • GOTO 2019 · GOTO Conferences · 42:02
- The largest campaign ever to stop publishers destroying games · Accursed Farms · 31:24
- I painted a Landscape with Mathematics · Inigo Quilez · 42:00
- 8 Bit & '8 Bitish' Graphics-Outside the Box · GDC Festival of Gaming · 1:25:34
- RiftSketch: Live coding in VR with the Oculus Rift, Firefox WebVR, JavaScript and Three.js · Brian Peiris · 10:36