The Voting System That's Actually Too Good for Politicians to Allow
Channel:CGP Grey · Length:6:47 · Published:2014-10-22 · Views:10533781
Summary
CGP Grey explains the Single Transferable Vote, a proportional ranked-ballot system, and why politicians have little incentive to adopt it. It is a short animated explainer of how multi-winner ranked voting works.
Why HN recommends it
HN's default link for explaining STV in any thread on voting reform, ranked choice or gerrymandering.
CGP Grey did a great video on STV — HN, 2017
US politics & elections · Politics & history (other)
Subtitles (excerpt)
Queen Lion is looking to make the elections in her animal kingdom more fair. Currently she divides her citizens into ranges each of which selects one representative to go to the jungle council which makes laws for the kingdom. But her citizens are unhappy, and it's easy to see why: the council is full of monkeys. Of course some of her citizens are monkeys, but not all of them. This council doesn't fairly represent her kingdom. Queen lion visits one of the ranges to find out what's wrong and how to fix it. In this range there five monkeys, four tigers, three owls, two lynx and one buffalo. One of each runs for representative and all citizens vote for their own species. The election rule is that the candidate with the most votes wins, which is the monkey. But it's a pretty unsatisfying result considering that 2/3rds of citizens in this range *aren't* monkeys and wouldn't vote for monkeys. This is the same across all the ranges of the kingdom, the monkeys have more votes than anybody else, so they win all the elections, even though they are a minority of the total population. Closer inspection reveals that the independent advisors hired to draw the range boundaries in the first place weren't as independent as they first appeared.
On Hacker News
Gerrymandering is a problem because we have a poor voting system. I'm not sure if a single transferrable vote (STV) is the best system, but it would significantly reduce the benefit of gerrymandering (and probably result in better candidates from both parties). CGP Grey did a great video on STV: [VIDEO] — CivBase, 2017-12
Ireland uses this appraoch. We call it STV. STV Explained -- [VIDEO] It just a better democracy because it's more representative. It's solves the "wasted vote" problem people have with democracy and why many democracies result in a two party system. This way it ensures your vote is counted and multiple parties exist. — s_dev, 2019-10
Now if only they would introduce something like Single Transferable Vote (entertaining CGPGrey video: [VIDEO] ), or another more effective voting system. Probably won't happen though, as it would seriously shake up politics as we know it. — lpolzer, 2019-03
erentz was probably referring to the single transferable vote system ( [LINK] ), which uses a ranked ballot in elections and results in relatively proportional representation. CGP grey explains it pretty well: [VIDEO] — khr, 2018-12
Elections are supposed to be bloodless revolutions. If you can't effect change through the electoral system, then the non violent solution is to revolutionize how we vote. Relevant videos (IMO) First Past The Post Voting - [LINK] Range Voting - [LINK] Single Transferable Vote - [VIDEO] Alternative Vote - [LINK] Mixed-Member Proportional Representation - [LINK] Bonus video This video will make you… — thelasthuman, 2018-11
Related videos
- How We Should Vote (Range Voting) · Undefined Behavior · 6:23
- The Voting System That Gives You Two Votes · CGP Grey · 4:29
- Secret Billionaire: The Chuck Feeney Story · atlanticphil · 57:09
- Try to Rule Fairly and You'll Be Overthrown · CGP Grey · 18:13
- George Lakoff: Moral Politics · University of California Television (UCTV) · 58:57
- Why Electronic Voting Is Still A Bad Idea · Tom Scott · 12:00
- Republic, Lost | Lawrence Lessig | Talks at Google · Talks at Google · 57:19
- London Swallowed a City but Couldn't Digest It. · CGP Grey · 4:47
- Antonin Scalia - On American Exceptionalism · AmericanRhetoric.com · 7:21
- The Cardboard Box Reform - Nixon's Ghost Bill & A Crucial Flaw in Democracy · CRI · 1:02:37
- The Coming Collapse of the Middle Class with Elizabeth Warren · University of California Television (UCTV) · 57:37
- We the People, and the Republic we must reclaim | Lawrence Lessig · TED · 18:19
- Why Your Vote Doesn't Count · CGP Grey · 6:31
- The UK Is a Country Made of Countries · CGP Grey · 5:14
- America Keeps Rejecting an ID Card It Already Has · CGP Grey · 7:15
- May 1, 1969: Fred Rogers testifies before the Senate Subcommittee on Communications · Road Less Marveled · 6:51