Why the Dutch Wait Less at Traffic Lights
Channel:Not Just Bikes · Length:10:34 · Published:2020-07-27 · Views:1200275
Summary
Not Just Bikes explains how Dutch traffic lights use early detection, transit priority and conflict-free design to cut waiting. The aim is to move as many people as possible rather than as many cars.
Why HN recommends it
Used as the standard reference for what genuinely smart traffic signals look like, in threads about traffic engineering and self-driving cars.
talking about length of crossings on wide road, traffic signals, priorities, etc. — HN, 2022
Transit, cities & urban planning
Subtitles (excerpt)
When I'm traveling somewhere, I hate traffic lights, and I go out of my way to find routes that avoid them. But, for some reason, I still find them interesting. I even own a real traffic light at home. When studying engineering in Canada, I had an exam question to design a state machine for a traffic light controller. It had to go green, then yellow, then red, and then repeat in the other direction. Easy enough. I would not want to take that exam question in the Netherlands because traffic lights are way more complicated here. There are several times where I've sat around watching traffic lights in the Netherlands with absolute fascination. Does anyone else do that, or is it just us engineers? Traffic lights in the Netherlands have so many interesting combinations, and they change depending on what traffic is detected and from where. Most cities in the world have detection circuits at low-traffic intersections to detect if there's a stopped car at a red light. But, traffic-dependent detectors, which detect approaching traffic and change the signals based on real-time traffic levels, are used at the majority of intersections in Amsterdam. And these kind of signals are much more common in the Netherlands in
On Hacker News
See the youtube channel Not Just Bikes[1], specifically videos like - "Why the Dutch wait less at traffic lights" - [VIDEO] argues that American traffic engineering is optimised for car movement, at the expense of pedestrians and bikes, whereas Dutch traffic engineering is to minimise conflict between vehicles and maximise movement of people overall. Leading to more complex but more efficient int… — jodrellblank, 2022-12
Here's a link to some traffic light systems that you can trust most of the time. But nothing is perfect, so you're still required to pay attention yourself too, of course. [VIDEO] — Kim_Bruning, 2021-12
In some European countries all of this is commonplace - check out the not just bikes video on the subject - [VIDEO] Detects if you are coming to the intersection and with what speed, and if there is no traffic blocking you automatically cycles the red lights so you don’t have to stop at all. — seer, 2025-10
As an extension of the argument the comment you're replying to was making: Many (most?) intersections in the Netherlands have early detection systems that change the light _before_ the car reaches it. But they didn't just do this for cars, they also do this for bikes. And public transit gets signal priority allowing buses and trams to almost always get green lights. They've spent the money improv… — ignormies, 2023-10
To give a simple example, the US spends a ton of infrastructure. Yet it doesn't even have really smart traffic lights like the Dutch do. [VIDEO] Just think about any large scale governmental software project and amplify that 10-100x. That's what I imagine :-) > The design of the website was overseen by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services and built by a number of federal contractors, mo… — oblio, 2023-01
Related videos
- Joe Armstrong & Jeremy Ruston - Intertwingling the Tiddlywiki with Erlang | Code Mesh LDN 18 · Code Sync · 44:38
- Arcologies · Isaac Arthur · 28:43
- The paradox of choice | Barry Schwartz | TED · TED · 20:23
- DjangoCon 2008 Keynote: Cal Henderson · Google for Developers · 1:02:43
- The Most IMPORTANT Video You'll Ever See (part 1 of 8) · wonderingmind42 · 9:17
- Self-filling water bottle: BUSTED! · Thunderf00t · 16:52
- Why Grocery Shopping is Better in Amsterdam · Not Just Bikes · 3:46
- The surprising science of happiness | Dan Gilbert · TED · 21:20
- Life is easy. Why do we make it so hard? | Jon Jandai | TEDxDoiSuthep · TEDx Talks · 15:10
- The Dutch Solution for Safer Sidewalks - Continuous Sidewalks · Not Just Bikes · 3:44
- Colonizing Mars · Isaac Arthur · 34:32
- The Most Powerful Computers You've Never Heard Of · Veritasium · 20:12
- a better way to count · jan Misali · 18:01
- Tiffany: The Name That Cheats Death · CGP Grey · 8:56
- [EPILEPSY WARNING] How fast should an unoptimized terminal run? · Molly Rocket · 51:03
- I'll Let Myself In: Tactics of Physical Pen Testers · Wild West Hackin' Fest · 44:55
- America Always Gets This Wrong (when building transit) · Not Just Bikes · 15:27
- Why Western Designs Fail in Developing Countries · Design Theory · 27:36
- The Trains that Subsidize Suburbia - GO Transit Commuter Rail · Not Just Bikes · 15:49
- Why This Channel Exists (and why I hate Houston) · Not Just Bikes · 17:02