The US Has More Tribes Than the World Has Countries

Channel:CGP Grey · Length:6:46 · Published:2019-11-24 · Views:7332946

Watch on YouTube

Summary

CGP Grey explains why "Indian" is often preferred over "Native American" in the United States, especially near reservations, and how many tribes exist in the US. He draws on conversations with people who identify as Indian.

Why HN recommends it

Cited again and again in terminology debates as a convincing source that many American Indians prefer the term Indian.

CGP Grey made a very convincing video on the argument that at least in the US, unexpectedly enough, "Indian" is probably the most appropriate term — HN, 2022

Social issues & culture · Language & linguistics

Subtitles (excerpt)

The first people who lived here named themselves. Across the continent, in hundreds of languages. The word for people - or the First People - was what they used. Other people existed, to trade and talk and fight with. But the continent was vast and travel slow. There were no horses and wouldn't be for millennia. No group could know all the others. So there was no single name for all. Then, from across the sea, came a new other people. Who brought with them great and terrible things. They too had a name for themselves in their own language. But they also brought a name for the First People: Indians. We are in the future from this past. And you in the future from my present (possibly the far future). And the word 'Indian' may have just made you uncomfortable. So let’s talk about words. Words are what we make them. Without the words surrounding them, without brains to interpret them, words are but whispers of wind. It’s a word’s utility to the speaker and the reaction of the listener that causes words to be born and to live and to die. Long after its first use in the New World, the early British and American Empires needed a word to collectively describe the First People. And 'Indian', despite its confused origins, was that word.

On Hacker News

CGP Grey made a very convincing video on the argument that at least in the US, unexpectedly enough, "Indian" is probably the most appropriate term to use for Native Americans for a multitude of reasons: [VIDEO] — deanCommie, 2022-01
I'd be a bit reluctant to quickly judge someone's exposure to the various terminology around this topic. CGP Grey has a good video on the terminology as used in the US [0]. From the video: " Talking to people over the last [sigh] 5 years revealed a strong correlation: the closer a person had ever been to a reservation, the more likely they would be to use the word 'indian'. The farther, the more … — daveslash, 2023-11
Tl;Dr: it's tricky. and because it's not that simple. I don't know your background and maybe you're from a first nation or tribe, but there isn't a common agreement between the populations of existing tribes and nations on what is offensive or incorrect. This isn't to say that any term is acceptable, but Indians, however incorrectly labeled by a colonizing group a few hundred years ago, is litera… — currydove, 2022-11
Many of the first people of what is now known by many as the United States prefer the label of "Indian" over the label "Native Americans". A very excellent (if also very "edutainment") exploration of labels and the label of "Indian", based on conversation with people who identify as "Indians", can be viewed here: [VIDEO] — lelandbatey, 2020-07
CGP Grey argues this same point: not only is Indian the legally correct term, but it’s the correct term in general. [VIDEO] — sillysaurusx, 2026-05

Related videos