Does Canada’s Bill C-16 Violate Free Speech or Protect Human Rights? | The Agenda

Channel:TVO Today · Length:54:58 · Published:2016-10-27 · Views:11516906

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A TVO current affairs panel debates Canada's Bill C-16, which added gender identity and expression to human rights law and the Criminal Code. Jordan Peterson argues it threatens free speech, and other guests respond.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it as a source for the compelled-speech argument and the debate around Peterson's position.

Law, policing & justice · Free speech, censorship & civil liberties · Social issues & culture

Subtitles (excerpt)

>> Steve: WHAT'S IN A NAME? POTENTIALLY A GREAT DEAL. UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO PSYCHOLOGY PROFESSOR JORDAN PETERSON HAS A FIGHT ON HIS HANDS AFTER OBJECTING TO PROPOSED LEGISLATION THAT HE SAYS WOULD VIOLATE HIS FREEDOM OF SPEECH BY FORCING HIM TO ADDRESS TRANSGENDERED PEOPLE USING THE PRONOUNS OF THEIR CHOOSING. JOINING US NOW TO BETTER UNDERSTAND THE ISSUE, AND DEBATE WHAT'S AT STAKE: IN VANCOUVER, B.C.: THERYN MEYER, TRANSGENDER PUNDIT AND YouTuber; IN THE NATION'S CAPITAL: KYLE KIRKUP, PROFESSOR OF LAW, UNIVERSITY OF OTTAWA. AND HERE IN STUDIO: JORDAN PETERSON, PROFESSOR OF PSYCHOLOGY, UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO; NICHOLAS MATTE, LECTURER, TRANSGENDER STUDIES AT U OF T; AND, MARY ROGAN, WHOSE ARTICLE ENTITLED "GROWING UP TRANS" IS FEATURED IN THE OCTOBER ISSUE OF THE WALRUS. GOOD TO HAVE YOU THREE HERE AND OUR TWO FRIENDS IN POINTS BEYOND. WE APPRECIATE EVERYBODY BEING ON THE PROGRAM FOR WHAT IS I THINK ONE OF THE HOTTEST TOPICS IN THE COUNTRY TODAY, PROFESSOR PETERSON, AND IT'S ALL BECAUSE OF YOU. I THINK BEFORE WE GO ANY FURTHER WITH OUR CONVERSATION HERE, I WANT TO GIVE PEOPLE A SENSE OF HOW HOT THIS HAS GOT, STARTING ON THE DOWNTOWN CAMPUS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO. SHELDON, IF YOU WOULD?

On Hacker News

That's exactly the problem. It's uncivil if I do it, but justified if they enforce it. Double standards much? To be clear: I don't give a flying f * about what you do with your body, but don't fire me if I happen to use a personal pronoun that doesn't match your feeling. You had no problem in disregarding my opinion, and felt the need to protect their views. Please take the time to view this vide… — Wellshit, 2016-11
I'm not sure if the compelled speech was actually adopted into law. I'm referring to Jordan Peterson's interview and senate hearing in relation to the law. [1] [VIDEO] [2] [LINK] — um_ya, 2020-06
Professor Nicholas Matte states it in this interview: [VIDEO] Not a really exotic belief in the core social justice circles. Though advocates tend to avoid stating it outright, since it's so easy to attack and so ridiculous. So it's generally left implicit. E.g. They'll just say, "X field is only 30% women, we must fight the sexism that causes this", leaving it as an unstated assumption. — Banthum, 2017-08
The idea (which is now becoming law in some places such as Canada [1]) is that some people do not identify as male and female but rather as something inbetween. So if you refer to them using the words 'he' or 'she' then that is an act of violence against them. The laws enacted then fine you if you refuse to use whatever pronoun they prefer in place of 'he' or 'she'. [2] Some examples are ze,them,… — jfaucett, 2016-11

Related videos