Renting vs. Buying a Home: What People Get Wrong

Channel:Ben Felix · Length:18:52 · Published:2025-05-11 · Views:981752

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Ben Felix argues that common beliefs about renting versus buying are wrong: homes are not great investments, mortgages are not a wealth hack, and ownership does not reliably bring happiness.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended as detailed math on rent versus buy, showing the choice is often roughly a wash.

Investing & personal finance

Subtitles (excerpt)

Real quick before I start, I will never send you an email and definitely not from a Gmail address. Please don't get scammed by whoever is doing this. Last year, I wrote an article for the Globe Mail detailing why renting a home is not always a bad financial decision, despite the common perception that it is. That article received hundreds of comments from readers, many of them exemplary of what people get wrong about the rent versus own decision for housing. People tend to assume that homes are great investments. They're not. that mortgages are a wealth-b buildinging hack. They help, but not as much as people think. That paying off a mortgage lowers your housing costs. It actually raises them. And that owning a home makes people happy. It might, but don't count on it. I'm Ben Felix, chief investment officer at PWL Capital, and I'm going to tell you what people get wrong about the rent versus own decision for housing. [Music] One of the worst ways to make the rent versus own decision is comparing the monthly cost of a mortgage payment to the monthly cost of rent. A mortgage payment is not the cost of living in a home. I hope that will become clear as we proceed through the video. Homes are generally terrible investments.

On Hacker News

Ben Felix, a Canadian portfolio manager that does personal finance videos and podcast, has been arguing for years that rent versus buy is often a wash financially, and that you should make the decision for non-financial resasons. * recent 2026 video: [LINK] * 2025a: [VIDEO] * 2025b: [LINK] * 2021: [LINK] * 2019: [LINK] The 2019 video goes over a handy "5% rule of thumb": start with the purchase p… — throw0101c, 2026-05
You’re right, the math is slightly more complicated than rent v. mortgage payment. Ben Felix, a popular financial YouTuber, made many a video about the math: [VIDEO] [LINK] — whymarrh, 2025-09
Sure, but that's demonstrably more to do with the actual financial position than the ownership status. If you own the house and no longer pay a mortgage then you're ipso facto wealthier — although you presumably do still pay property tax. During the period of the mortgage, while rent wouldn't necessarily be cheap, it would be cheaper than the TCO of the house. The overall financial consideration … — zahlman, 2025-08
C. it's the only one that has you in the arena. There's no guaranteed outcome, but money itself is a team-sport. I'm a simple man myself, so I'm answering in order to verify my own reasoning. A. will have negative returns from inflation. D. defends against inflation but is too conservative. B. There's arguably negative value in holding more equity in terms of opportunity cost since you already ha… — apsurd, 2025-11

Related videos