How Corruption Destroys Armies - Theft, Graft, and Russian failure in Ukraine

Channel:Perun · Length:57:21 · Published:2022-05-29 · Views:2699418

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Perun analyzes how corruption and theft in defence procurement hollowed out the Russian military before its invasion of Ukraine. It explains the mechanics of graft and how it degrades capability.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended as a long but insightful explanation of how corruption works inside institutions.

Both these videos are long, but they had a lot of interesting ideas and insight on this topic — HN, 2022

Geopolitics & foreign policy · Military history & warfare

Subtitles (excerpt)

Before its invasion of Ukraine, the Russian army projected a certain image to the world. It was one of a modern and capable fighting force, the world's second most powerful army equipped with state of the art T-14 tanks, Ratnik infantry combat systems, 5th generation fighter jets. It was a near peer to NATO or, as far as some commentators were concerned, actually a peer or even superior to the United States military. After the invasion of Ukraine we saw a very different side of the Russian military. We saw a force with rations 6/7 years out of date, we saw a force with knock-off tyres that hadn't been maintained, tanks that didn't have enough fuel, and troops that lacked even the most rudimentary of training and combat equipment. I've gone into before why budgeting and strategy didn't really align with producing the army that Russia needed as it moved into Ukraine. But even with the budget going to the wrong places you could argue, Russia should have had a more powerful military than it turned out to. It had all sorts of purchasing power parity advantages. Things are cheaper in Russia, they don't pay their troops very much. The budget they had should have gone far enough to produce a far more capable military than

On Hacker News

The paperwork is an attempt(usually misguided) to stop the corruption. The idea is that if you have to account and document all actions you will have act in the proscribed manner and not in a way that benefits you. This usually fails for the reason you posted. I am not really sure how you are supposed to stop corruption once it gets rooted in your society. It is a vile and subversive menace that … — somat, 2022-10
> Maybe but those are big assumptions. Does the USA inspect it's missiles in the middle of nowhere? The US almost certainly does, but the Russians might not. They've been shown to have neglected routine maintenance in ways that caused very critical problems for their military (e.g. they lost a lot of expensive advanced vehicles, because their unmaintained knock-off tires disintegrated). Both thes… — tablespoon, 2022-07
As the level of corruption grows, the organisation starts to stumble and eventually gets sued to dust. An interesting youtube on Russian corruption grew to such huge levels thatover 80% of the budget was diverted. Soldiers stole engines/tires/optics/fuel and so on and the invasion of Kiev failed. [LINK] [VIDEO] — aurizon, 2023-09
> My impression was that Russia's failures in Ukraine mostly stemmed from failures in their logistics and doctrine rather than their technology. Also lack of proper spending priorities: [LINK] And corruption: [VIDEO] — tablespoon, 2022-07
Yeah, I edited it out because I knew discussion would rathole on whether or not the U.S. military is effective, while the larger point I'm making is about institutions (in general) and their ability to change. Russia's performance in the Ukraine war is a good example: they have all the war materials [1], but they suck at waging war because the institutions are so corrupt that they suck at waging … — nostrademons, 2022-07

Related videos