Consciousness is Not a Computation (Roger Penrose) | AI Podcast Clips

Channel:Lex Fridman · Length:22:59 · Published:2020-04-04 · Views:2315997

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Clip from Lex Fridman's podcast with Roger Penrose in which Penrose argues that consciousness is not a computation. He discusses Godel-style arguments and the possible role of quantum effects in microtubules.

Why HN recommends it

Pointed to in consciousness and AI threads as the best-known statement of Penrose's view, which commenters find interesting even when they disagree.

I don't take Roger's view about consciousness for granted but it is very interesting nevertheless. — HN, 2020

Tech pioneers & interviews · Quantum physics · Consciousness & cognition

Subtitles (excerpt)

I'm trying to say that whatever consciousness is it's not a computation yes it's not a physical process which can be described by computation but it nevertheless could be so one of the interesting models that you've proposed as the orchestrated objective reduction yeah that's going from there you say so I say I have no idea so I wrote this book through my scientific career I thought you know when I'm retired I have enough time to write a sort of popular ish book which I will explain my ideas and puzzles but I like beautiful things about physics and mathematics and this puzzle about computability in consciousness and so on and in the process of writing this book well I thought I'd do it when I retired I didn't actually I would didn't wait that long because there was a radio discussion between edward fredkin and marvin minsky and they were talking about what computers could do and they were answering and entering a big room it imagined entering this big room with the other end of the room two computers were talking to each other and as you walk up to the computers they will have communicated to each other more ideas concepts things than the entire human race had ever commute that yes so I thought well know where you're

On Hacker News

Roger Penrose talked about this with Lex Fridman. The anesthesiologist Stuart Hameroff is looking into how anesthesia affects microtubules and the implications for consciousness. Penrose is intrigued by the symmetry of microtubules and the possibility for this symmetry to enable quantum coherence to be accessible biologically. His larger point is that consciousness is not a computation. [VIDEO] R… — aamargulies, 2022-07
Consciousness is Not a Computation (Roger Penrose) | AI Podcast Clips [VIDEO] Full episode: [LINK] I don't take Roger's view about consciousness for granted but it is very interesting nevertheless. — marius_k, 2020-12
I think it was on this site that someone posted the very interesting perspectives on consciousness by Roger Penrose.[2] From that I found this video by Dr. Stuart Hameroff, M.D.: Microtubules & quantum consciousness.[1] Higly recommended. [1]: [LINK] [2]: [VIDEO] — kebman, 2020-08
The question is answered in the full title: > "Gödel's theorem debunks the most important AI myth. AI will not be conscious" Same statement from Penrose here with Lex Friedman: "Consciousness is Not a Computation" [1]. [1] [VIDEO] — qrios, 2025-03
The question is whether consciousness is computable. Can a Turing machine be conscious? Probably not. [LINK] [VIDEO] — Mike_12345, 2023-03

Related videos