Is the EU Democratic? Does Your Vote Matter?

Channel:Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell · Length:7:55 · Published:2019-05-19 · Views:5630715

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Kurzgesagt explains how the European Union is governed, how its officials are elected or appointed, and whether a citizen's vote actually matters.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters point to it as a quick factual primer on EU institutions when threads get into EU politics and policy.

Here is a quick video explaining how it works — HN, 2022

Geopolitics & foreign policy · Politics & history (other)

Subtitles (excerpt)

Being a citizen of the European Union means that many aspects of our lives are regulated by a weird entity. It feels like a huge bureaucracy is making decisions over our heads. Many Europeans think that their vote in the EU elections doesn't count, and that the EU is not democratic. How democratic is the EU really? And, does your vote actually achieve anything? In democratic states, public policies are based on the will of the people. But, the people are not a coherent thing. Countless different groups are battling for influence and power to establish laws and rules that benefit them. In a working democracy, there are checks and balances that are supposed to create a fair environment where these battles can be fought. Term limits stop factions from dominating too much. But all of this ends at our borders. International politics are not democratic, but anarchic. No central authority is powerful enough to ensure fairness, or enforce laws, so the only law is the tyranny of the strongest, and anarchy. So for most of human history, powerful countries took what they wanted from others either by extortion or by violence. After World War Two, the United Nations were founded to overcome this anarchy

On Hacker News

> > Ursula von der Leyen was not elected by EU citizens > But was she not elected by EU members of parliment, who were elected by EU citizens? This is a common argument when criticizing the EU, but in the end everybody is elected by the people of EU (directly or indirectly). Here is a quick video explaining how it works: [VIDEO] — BadOakOx, 2022-06
Thanks for taking the time to think about it. > Democracy itself always gives rights to the majority against the will of the minority. this is true and it has a name I believe; the "Tyranny of the Majority", I think. > The tyranny of the majority (or tyranny of the masses) is an inherent weakness to majority rule in which the majority of an electorate pursues exclusively its own objectives at the… — dijit, 2022-05
All EU officials are elected directly or elected/assigned by the people that were elected. This will help you to get the facts straight: [VIDEO] — tasubotadas, 2019-07
Which is about the equal to the EU. Council of the EU [1] has similar function as the senate in the US. The council is made up of the heads of governments, as elected, by the member countries. The council proposes the commission, which is then left for the EU parliament to confirm. This very close, pretty much about equal to the election process of the US senate before the 17th amendment in 1912.… — Gwypaas, 2022-06
I’ve thought about this since last year, and I can’t understand how this proposal has been able to survive this long. First of all, the EU is very pro-business, which means it should be pro-encryption. Second, the structures of its governing bodies does not make it very prone to populism. Based on what I know from this Kurzgesagt video: [VIDEO] Is this all some hidden plot to turn the EU into a t… — vages, 2021-04

Related videos