"Debate" American Style: Our Top Orators in Action
Channel:Peter Schiff · Length:5:00 · Published:2014-05-04 · Views:928020
Summary
A short clip from the 2014 college debate championship, posted by a commentator who criticizes the winning performance as not being a real debate. It shows a fast, unconventional style of competitive debate.
Why HN recommends it
Used as a cited example in threads criticizing the direction of competitive school and college debate.
US politics & elections · Social issues & culture · Education & learning
Subtitles (excerpt)
There's no arguing it. Towson University's debate team wins, claiming an historic win. They are the first all-black women's team to win the Cross Examination Debate Association's national championship. This morning, we have two of the team members here. We have Amina Ruffin and Korey Johnson, both here to talk about the the major victory. Ladies, way to go. Congratulations. You've You've made so many people proud in this area. Now, we want to pick your brain a little bit as we admire your huge trophy, by the way. That's ridiculous. But, I'm going to ask you first. We'll start with you, Amina. What was the topic, first of all? Um, the topic was restricting presidential war powers authority. Um, we got the topic in about July, um, and we started doing our research then. We've been supplementing our research throughout the season. So, where do you go from there? You know, when you start preparing for a national competition, once you know the topic, what's next? Well, you do a lot of research. In order to prepare for it, because there are several different tournaments. And so, being able to transition through each tournament and able to respond to opponents' arguments. So, just a lot of preparation.
On Hacker News
I remember seeing this video a while ago: [VIDEO] Is this actually indicative of the kind of structured debate that happens in colleges? — livinginfear, 2023-07
I don't know much about debating competitions, but I was floored when I saw this video when researching this. [VIDEO] If this is real and not a parody, it seems like whatever scoring system they use incentivizes the wrong behavior even before you get into idealogical debates. — logicalmonster, 2023-06
If anyone has a doubt as to how far "debate" has fallen, this should be an eye-opening case-in-point: [VIDEO] [edit: Flagged? Really?? - this video exposes the very absurdity discussed in the article. A Championship debate team doing what few educated persons would recognize or identify as debate.] — jackhack, 2017-10
I don't know how bad it is at the high school level, but it does get worse as you go up to the University level... For an example, take the 2014 CEDA Championship Debate held at Indiana University - [VIDEO] * It seems that all the original videos from the above have been removed (from youtube), only clips are available. For those that are interested, a response to the criticism of the above "deba… — powertower, 2017-10
I dont know if it is acceptable to post YouTube links on HN, but here is a recording of recent national champions.[1] That it is even called debate is tragic. 1. [VIDEO] — nnfy, 2017-10
Related videos
- How to Speak · MIT OpenCourseWare · 1:03:42
- George Lakoff: Moral Politics · University of California Television (UCTV) · 58:57
- Music Theory and White Supremacy · Adam Neely · 44:01
- Why Electronic Voting Is Still A Bad Idea · Tom Scott · 12:00
- Republic, Lost | Lawrence Lessig | Talks at Google · Talks at Google · 57:19
- Alain de Botton: Status Anxiety · Alain de Botton · 2:23:07
- Antonin Scalia - On American Exceptionalism · AmericanRhetoric.com · 7:21
- The Cardboard Box Reform - Nixon's Ghost Bill & A Crucial Flaw in Democracy · CRI · 1:02:37
- Confessions of a Converted Lecturer: Eric Mazur · UMBCtube · 1:20:08
- The Coming Collapse of the Middle Class with Elizabeth Warren · University of California Television (UCTV) · 57:37
- Marty Lobdell - Study Less Study Smart · Pierce College District WA · 59:55
- We the People, and the Republic we must reclaim | Lawrence Lessig · TED · 18:19
- Why Your Vote Doesn't Count · CGP Grey · 6:31
- RSA ANIMATE: Changing Education Paradigms · Royal Society of Arts · 11:40
- Alan Kay: Doing with Images Makes Symbols (Full Version) · Kenneth Friedman · 1:37:44
- America Keeps Rejecting an ID Card It Already Has · CGP Grey · 7:15