The Dark History of "Left-Wing" Zionism

Channel:Bes D. Marx · Length:51:18 · Published:2024-02-18 · Views:141588

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A long-form video essay on the history of labor or 'left-wing' Zionism, drawing on historians of Palestine and Zionism to argue it played a role in dispossessing Palestinians.

Why HN recommends it

Cited as a source in Israel-Palestine threads for the claim that labor Zionist groups drove the Nakba.

Geopolitics & foreign policy · World history

Subtitles (excerpt)

Communism has never worked, except in this place. Benjamin Netanyahu is a fascistic dictator, and if only a leftist were to lead Israel, things would be so much better both for Israelis and Palestinians. It's not Zionism that's the problem. It's right-wing Israeli politicians and the Palestinian terrorists which are preventing Israelis and Palestinians to coexist peacefully together. One of the, if not the greatest myth preventing people to arrive at a correct analysis and position regarding the Israeli occupation in Palestine, is that there's a progressive Zionism, and that the genocide on the Palestinian people is the fault of an impractical, bad policy decision of the right-wing alliance government. So, today we're going to dive deep into the history of socialist Zionism, which isn't just any Zionist current. It has been the dominating tendency for most of the 20th century, being mainly responsible colonial expansion and dispossession in the early decades, culminating in the displacement of over 80% of the Palestinian population during the Nakba in 1948. This is part two of my series on Zionism. In part one, we talked about the origins of Zionism, so it's important you watch that one as well. Left-wing and liberal Zionism, which is both just liberal, still

On Hacker News

The expected Zionist modus operandi, whitewash Zionist crimes, then blame the victim for responding. Your "socialist" argument is a weak attempt to hide behind a political label. It doesn't matter what they called themselves. The "socialist"[1] Haganah and Palmach were the main engines of the Nakba. The distinction between them and the Irgun was a public relations strategy, a "good cop, bad cop" … — kalberg6429, 2025-09
When he writes "In the Palestine Mandate, Jews and Palestinians got along just fine" he clearly means that the centuries of peaceful co-existence before the arrival of Zionists are evidence that Zionism was and still is the root cause of hostilities and violence. That event which you referenced didn't happen in a vacuum since at that point Zionist colonization[1] was already in full force for dec… — jedimind, 2024-10
You can disagree all you want, some people even disagree on if the holocaust happened but no one takes them seriously. The history of Zionism and its goal to colonize Palestine (long before the holocaust even happened) and their ruthless methods of colonization are thoroughly documented[0][1]. [0] [LINK] [1] The History of "Socialist" Zionism | Leftist Zionists did the Nakba & founded Israel [VID… — kelthuzad, 2024-05

Related videos