Richard Dawkins demonstrates laryngeal nerve of the giraffe

Channel:MysOxen · Length:4:04 · Published:2010-06-14 · Views:613389

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A clip from Channel 4's Inside Nature's Giants in which Richard Dawkins shows the recurrent laryngeal nerve of the giraffe during a dissection. The nerve takes a long detour down the neck and back up.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it as the canonical example that evolution is not optimal and can get stuck in local maxima.

The bit about the recurrent laryngeal nerve of the giraffe is particulary memorable — HN, 2024

Evolution & genetics · Animals & nature

Subtitles (excerpt)

we get used to the idea that evolution is so good at producing beautiful elegant animals that look as though they've been designed we forget that sometimes they're not perfect and there are imperfections and the imperfections are very revealing because they're exactly the kind of imperfections you'd expect from the accidents of History if there were no designer there's a nerve called the recurrent lingal which runs from the brain and its end organ is the larynx and you think it would just go there but in a human what it does is goes down into the chest loops around one of the main arteries in the chest then goes straight back up again obviously a ridiculous detour no engineer would ever make a mistake like that in our bodies the lenial nerve takes a Securus route but what happens in an animal with a neck as long as this it's one of the great evolutionary enigmas that Richard Dawkins is Keen to resolve In the Flesh interestingly it's never been dissected out or only once before has it ever been dissected out in its full length and that was in 1838 don't cut it at this crucial moment too good Anonymous for that you have to trust me now what I'm actually holding here is the beginning of that nerve it actually

On Hacker News

The blog post recommended the TV show "inside nature's giants", and I second it. The bit about the recurrent laryngeal nerve of the giraffe is particulary memorable: [VIDEO] — ufo, 2024-09
Good catch. It seems like an artifact of working and editing a query until they got what they wanted - certainly not a BigQuery restriction. (like this [VIDEO] ) Note that the published query scans 2.25 TB of data. While impressive, for a better workflow and cost management I would split it into a 2 step process: - First extract all the files I'm interested in to a separate table (all pom.xmls?).… — fhoffa, 2017-03
Evolution most certainly DOES get stuck in local maxima: [VIDEO] . Also, it's quite easy for me to imagine an animal like an angel, with arms and wings. Tetrapods only have 4 limbs to work with though. For bats to gain wings they had to lose their front legs. — adevine, 2016-01
A rule of thumb is not a law. Form doesn't always follow function even in nature and evolution: [VIDEO] Also styles and fads like "minimalism" and "flat design" are forms that do not follow function but are really forms that enforce function. Which is why they're fads and go away after enough people jump on the bandwagon and realize the fad's flaw and limitations. — ChrisNorstrom, 2012-12

Related videos