Exact Instructions Challenge - THIS is why my kids hate me. | Josh Darnit

Channel:Josh Darnit · Length:7:23 · Published:2017-01-26 · Views:3894214

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A family video in which kids write instructions for making a peanut butter and jelly sandwich and a parent follows them exactly as written, with comic results. It demonstrates how precise instructions must be.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it to teach kids computational thinking and as a joke whenever specs, requirements, or LLM prompts are taken too literally.

this video is a great way to show how difficult it is to teach a machine to do something and how clear instructions can help get things done — HN, 2019

Arts & entertainment (other) · Education & learning

Subtitles (excerpt)

- You're not even making any sense. - Step one, get two pieces of bread out. Got 'em. (bread hits counter) Get a butter knife and get some PB. Take one piece of bread, spread it around with the butter knife. - No dad! With the peanut butter! - I'm just doing what it says. It says, take one piece of bread, spread it around with the butter knife. - Hold on. - Get some jelly, rub it on the other half of the bread. (knife clatters) - No dad! Open the jelly. - Well, it doesn't say to do that. Put the breads together on top of each other. Take a big bite. (Evan laughing) This doesn't taste like a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. Fail! (fail buzzer rings) - Mm, yeah, oh yeah, mm. - Sorry, I had to make it extremely specific. - Oh good, I'm starving. Take two pieces of white bread out of the bag. Take the lid off the jar of peanut butter. Get a butter knife and stick it inside of the peanut butter jar. (knife hits jar) With the knife, scoop a bit of peanut butter out of the-- - A bit, that means a lot! - A bit means a lot? - In my world. - Spread your scoop of peanut butter onto one of your pieces of bread with the knife. All right. There we go. - You're doing better than before though. - Open the jelly jar. Squeeze it onto the other piece of bread.

On Hacker News

1. Tell them what to do but do not tell them how to do it. (Just give a few pointers otherwise they'll be lost.) 2. Give them a playground to fail - Offload any non-business critical tasks and let them make mistakes. No one I know ever learnt programming without making any mistakes. Immediately tell them about best practices and how to avoid such mistakes in future. 3. Show them the impact of the… — srirangr, 2019-04
Have you seen the exact instruction challenge on youtube? I thought it was a great segue into technical thinking for young kids. [VIDEO] — zyang, 2017-02
As a ML researcher and a degree holding physicist, I'm really hesitant to use the words "understanding" and "describing" (much less hesitant) around these models. I don't find the language helpful and think it's mostly hateful tbh. The reason we use math in physics is because of its specificity. The same reason coding is so hard [0,1]. I think people aren't giving themselves enough credit here fo… — godelski, 2025-06
I've seen this video a while ago, where a father does this with his kids: [VIDEO] Lots of frustration about the stupid robot and I guess your school kids weren't much different. — ygra, 2018-08
Reminds me of the "Exact Instructions Challenge" videos where kids write instructions for some everyday task - like making a PB&J sandwich - and parents, hilariously, follow the instructions verbatim. [VIDEO] — wigiv, 2024-03

Related videos