Computers for Cynics 2 - It All Went Wrong at Xerox PARC

Channel:TheTedNelson · Length:14:00 · Published:2012-05-28 · Views:22980

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Ted Nelson, in his Computers for Cynics series, gives a critical history of Xerox PARC's vision of personal computing. He lists what he sees as the limitations and wrong turns in PARC's approach to the desktop and documents.

Why HN recommends it

HN readers treat it as a contrarian counterpoint to the usual PARC mythology, though one commenter noted a few apparent mistakes in it.

Nelson's history is a breath of fresh air. — HN, 2014

History of computing · GUI, HCI & interface history · Tech pioneers & interviews

Subtitles (excerpt)

hi I'm Ted Nelson with another serving of computers for cynic today's proposition it all went wrong at Xerox park for the first six minutes I'll tell you the standard story and then we'll get down to business first let's start with the legend the people at Xerox Palo ala Research Center called Xerox Park are treated as gods in the standard Computer History they created the modern computer world as we know it they took the bad old geeky computer with its keyboard commands and the bad old text editing programs with their keyboard commands and built instead a magic toy shop they gave us M Mouse pointing multiple windows on the screen pull down menus applications running in separate Windows word processing with fancy fonts uh sometimes called desktop publishing virtually every computer in the world now has this structure usually called the modern guei or graphical user interface but many other graphical interfaces are possible so let's give proper credit and call it what it is the park user interface or pooy preh history Xerox and how it grew once there was a company called haloid that made photographic supplies chemical and photographic paper but in the 1930s they bought a patent on a process that would make pictures by

On Hacker News

Thank you. Nelson does a great job enumerating the limitations of PARC's vision and the capabilities absent from PARC's work. After being exposed to PARC's self-congratulatory self-promotion for decades, Nelson's history is a breath of fresh air. This is not to devalue what PARC accomplished, but that its accomplishments must be taken in perspective. It All Went Wrong at Xerox PARC is also on You… — tod222, 2014-04
This comment jogged my memory of a Ted Nelson video subtitled 'It all went wrong at Xerox PARC' : [VIDEO] — seltzered_, 2023-12
It's Ted Nelson rattling through some of his computer-history notes on camera. So it's good material, but it's much better presented in his enjoyable and reasonably-priced book /Geeks Bearing Gifts/ [LINK] . I noted a couple of apparent mistakes: at [VIDEO] Nelson says that Xerox paid Jobs to look at the PARC work, while AFAIK Apple in fact paid Xerox, in pre-IPO Apple stock. He also suggested th… — leoc, 2014-01

Related videos