Self-filling water bottle: BUSTED!

Channel:Thunderf00t · Length:16:52 · Published:2016-05-08 · Views:1096469

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Thunderf00t debunks the Fontus self-filling water bottle, arguing that pulling meaningful amounts of water from air with a small solar-powered device is thermodynamically impractical.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in atmospheric water harvesting threads as a debunking of products that promise drinking water from thin air.

Thunderf00t has debunked a bunch of other enterprises doing water from the air — HN, 2021

Fundamental physics · Engineering & making (other)

Subtitles (excerpt)

if you're an adventurer you know the anxiety that comes with running out of water in the middle of a tour the last thing you want is dehydration when you're miles away from home fontus is a self-filling water bottle that allows you to plan your adventures without having to worry about heavy water loads or where to find the next River or the next gas station so a device that magically pulls water out of the yeah I wanted to create a bottle that would never run dry a bottle that fills itself for me it's like magic because out of thin air and sun we are bringing this bottle to fill itself with drinkable water a bottle that gives you the freedom to go anywhere and yes it's complete [ __ ] but it's not stopped it from being given about a third of a million dollars in featured all over the place so imagine you have a glass of water and you put a seal on the top the water will establish a vapor pressure basically some of that water will evaporate into the air and you'll reach a constant value an equilibrium where the water is evaporating at the same rate it's condensing and whatever the value is is called 100% humidity and it is temperature dependent in fact let's take this for a 1 lit pot bottle so if I were to condense all of the gas in this bottle it would give me

On Hacker News

Check out Thunderf00t's videos cricising solar water collectors, e.g.: - [LINK] - Zero Mass Water: BUSTED! "Honestly, it drives me crazy how many people have reinvented the dehumidifier, put a solar panel on it, and the media has danced around like theyve just saved the world!" - [VIDEO] - Self-filling water bottle: BUSTED! " The fact that its thermodynamically impossible seem to stop 'science co… — jodrellblank, 2022-03
Wow, I was under the impression that atmospheric water harvesting (AWH) was extremely inefficient. I don't have any numbers but things like [1][2] seem to indicate that AWH is currently not very useful. The paper doesn't seem to (if I read it correctly) actually address this directly, instead it talks about how much energy is needed to extract water at different relative humidity levels and facto… — hansvs, 2021-10
Nope, there's no magic or free lunch. It depends heavily on local conditions which might not always be suitable. Thunderf00t has debunked a bunch of other enterprises doing water from the air: [LINK] [VIDEO] [LINK] [LINK] etc — imglorp, 2021-08
I was initially afraid this was going to be a solar self-filling water bottle KS. [0] So, it's basically a porous mirror of the tried-and-true emergency solar water collector design. It seems legitimately legit. I wonder if an extremely dark material (nanotube appliqué[1]) on a porous material would be able to process water faster? The trillion dollar question is: How much material do you need to… — failwhaleshark, 2021-04

Related videos