Copyright is Brain Damage | Nina Paley | TEDxMaastricht

Channel:TEDx Talks · Length:18:24 · Published:2015-10-21 · Views:90538

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Nina Paley's TEDxMaastricht talk arguing against copyright and for copyleft and free culture. She argues that restricting ideas harms creativity and that culture belongs to everyone.

Why HN recommends it

Brought up in copyright, public domain and AI-training debates as a provocative argument for abolishing copyright.

had a great talk five years ago on how restricting information is a form of cultural cancer — HN, 2020

Hacker culture & free software · Law, policing & justice · Free speech, censorship & civil liberties

Subtitles (excerpt)

In 2008, I finished a feature film called Sita Sings the Blues. Sita Sings the Blues used music by a singer from the 1920s named Annette Hanshaw. And those songs should have been in the public domain by the 1980s, but they weren't because of retroactive copyright extensions. I knew this when I was making the film and I used those songs anyway because they were essential. Whoops. At the time, I didn't know that much about copyright or intellectual property. I did know that copyright terms were too long. Uh I thought retroactive copyright extensions were insane, but I never fundamentally doubted the concept of intellectual property. I'm an artist and so that was probably the only kind of property I would ever have. Uh and um the idea that I could just think of something and make that property was really intoxicating. In 2008, while distributors movie distributors were going bankrupt right and left, it fell on me to clear the licenses for Sita Sings the Blues. So I entered the Kafka-esque copyright system trying to do that. Uh and every step of the way, people told me you know, this system might be annoying, but the same Kafka-esque nightmare is protecting your intellectual property. So it's annoying, but don't you want your intellectual property protected?

On Hacker News

Copyright Is Brain Damage by Nina Paley [1] claimed that culture is like a bunch of neurons passing and evolving data to each other, and copyright is like severing the ties between the neurons, like brain damage. It also presented [2] an alternative way of viewing art and science, as products of the common culture, not a product purely from the creator, to be privatised. This sounds really releva… — CaptainFever, 2023-12
Yes! Same takeaway, and the main reason I published my thesis online first, turning it into a video tutorial to boot: [LINK] . Specifically I was frustrated at all the sources I had to get behind various kinds of walls, pay- and otherwise: [LINK] Nina Paley (from Rita Sings the Blues ) had a great talk five years ago on how restricting information is a form of cultural cancer that is very relevan… — qqn, 2020-04
It crashes on the first video i tried: [VIDEO] Relevant part: > ERROR: [youtube] [VIDEO] Sign in to confirm you’re not a bot. Use --cookies-from-browser or --cookies for the authentication. See [LINK] for how to manually pass cookies. Also see [LINK] for tips on effectively exporting YouTube cookies The app provides no way to pass flags, though (and the browser is confirmed to be logged in to you… — sgbeal, 2026-04
> Do you enjoy feature films? Video games? Television shows? not really no, I like stand up comedy, music, indie films, art that people make because they feel compelled to make art, not because they've done the math on the best return-on-investment My ideal funding model is kickstarteresque, raise X amount and then publish I consider copyright contradictory to free speech, I can say whatever I wa… — jazzyjackson, 2022-07
"Copyright is brain damage." "Copyright has become the single most serious impediment to access to knowledge." "Today we recognize that knowledge is not only a public good but also a global or international public good.We have also come to recognize that knowledge is central to successful development. The international community, through institutions like the World Bank, has a collective responsi… — dredmorbius, 2018-02

Related videos