the sham legacy of Richard Feynman

Channel:Angela Collier · Length:2:48:11 · Published:2024-11-28 · Views:1182335

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Physicist Angela Collier's nearly three-hour critique of Richard Feynman's public legacy. She examines how his books, written with Ralph Leighton, shaped a mythologized great-man image, and covers his personal behavior.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends it as a sobering counterpoint to the Feynman myth for people whose view comes from Surely You're Joking.

Her video on Feynman is long and detailed, and very sobering. I highly recommend it. — HN, 2025

Tech pioneers & interviews · Fundamental physics · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

you know Richard feeman right he's the super amazing physicist you know famous for picking locks staring at an atomic blast being the only physicist to ever think outside the box flirting with his students he was super good with the ladies um playing the bongo drums and not brushing his teeth I I just think it's kind of weird that like the most famous physicist is known for his personality rather than his physics like internet people do you know the physics that Richard fean did it was like a lot of things do you know isn't it [Music] weird here's an example from this book I read earlier this year called love theoretically and in it she's like listing famous physicist and she's like Einstein Newton Fineman and like Einstein we get it you know relativity Newton Gravity the Apple we get it Fineman what did Fineman do exactly this is honestly probably a bad example to do like for my audience people who like and watch physics videos you guys probably can come up with words to say you can say like findan diagrams probably but like do you know what he did and do you know it on the same level that you know what Newton did I don't think so that's because this is a weird list don't get me wrong findan amazing Nobel prize winning physicist he contributed a lot but

On Hacker News

Because she thoroughly de-articulates the fabricated mystique around Feynman, and openly discusses the toxic effect his legacy has had on science. (Including the fact that a lot of his legacy was fabricated by people that either admired him, or wished to capitalize on that legacy.) Her video on Feynman is long and detailed, and very sobering. I highly recommend it. It absolutely/expertly challeng… — artifact_44, 2025-02
Astrophysicist Angela Collier's video essay "the sham legacy of Richard Feynman" [0] is a good introduction. Her accounts of her own encounters with "Feynman bros" are heart-wrenching. [0] [VIDEO] — renhanxue, 2025-06
He hasn't written a single book (surprising I know), I assume you're talking about "Surely you're joking, Mr. Feynman", which contains exaggerated anecdotes designed to make Feynman look like a hero. That one was written by a fanboy (Ralph Leighton) based on stories that Feynman told him, which have been revealed to be either fake or exaggerations (they found notes in his office of him writing an… — tovej, 2025-02
I'd be careful taking anything from "surely you're joking" as a fact btw. There's a good popsci comms video on why here [VIDEO] — hughesjj, 2024-12
You may want to watch this if Surely You're Joking read years ago is your main reference point: [VIDEO] — blackenedgem, 2024-12

Related videos