Milton Friedman - Why Tax Reform Is Impossible

Channel:LibertyPen · Length:14:28 · Published:2012-06-29 · Views:241430

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Milton Friedman explains why the US tax code is enormously complex and why meaningful reform is unlikely. He argues that politicians profit from the complexity, since tax breaks are products they sell and the code works as a tool of reward and punishment. The clip is about 14 minutes from his lecture series.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters cite it whenever a thread touches on tax complexity, loopholes, or why companies like Intuit benefit from a convoluted tax system.

There is a good Milton Friedman video wherein he explains why tax reform won't happen in the United States. — HN, 2014

Investing & personal finance · Microeconomics & behavioral economics · US politics & elections

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] why is it that the tax system is so complicated why are the rates so graduated why do we have a tax system which has an almost infinite number of rules and regulations so that nobody in this room could possibly know them all with tax rates that started for an individual at 14% on the personal income tax and go up to 70% and that's on top of corporate taxes so that the owners of Corporations pay a double tax why do we have such a system well one argument people might make is that it's for Equity but it's not so you can go from the left of the political Spectrum to the right and have a hard time finding anybody who will say that our present personal income tax system is an equitable system people who are fundamentally in the same economic Position will pay very different taxes according to all sorts of accidental elements the form in which their property is whether they've been clever or not at getting tax shelters all sorts of things that ought to have nothing to do with the tax burden well then if we don't have it for Equity maybe we have this complex and highly graduated system for Revenue not so it doesn't yield any Revenue let me demonstrate that to you in a very simple way suppose you were to consider the following change in a law you leave the personal

On Hacker News

Somewhat relevant talk by Milton Friedman that I found enlightening when thinking about these tax matters (economics of tax shelters, tax cuts being the "product" politicians "sell", etc.): [VIDEO] (I strongly recommend watching all of it, but around 5:50 in he talks about why the tax system will remain complicated if you have an internet attention span). — tolmasky, 2013-05
Perhaps if taxes were less punitive and confiscatory people would be less likely to be creative in their avoidance. Lowering and simplifying taxes would increase revenues (per the Laffer Curve,) however that would result in politicians not being as powerful. Milton Friedman explains this brilliantly: [VIDEO] — briandear, 2017-04
There is a good Milton Friedman video wherein he explains why tax reform won't happen in the United States. The key is that the ideal goals of a tax system (e.g. generate lots of revenue with little inefficiency and little impact on taxpayers' personal financial situation and few unequally distributed loopholes like corporate tax avoidance) are not the goals of lawmakers who define the tax system… — baddox, 2014-01
Intuit isn’t the problem. Politicians are. See Milton Friedman on this subject. A complicated tax code is used to reward and punish people. The tax code was complex long before Intuit came around. [VIDEO] — briandear, 2022-03
Let’s not blame Intuit for this. Blame the politicians. Here’s Milton Friedman on the reason the tax code is intentionally complicated: [VIDEO] — briandear, 2022-03

Related videos