Why Cars Rarely Crash into Buildings in the Netherlands

Channel:Not Just Bikes · Length:6:16 · Published:2020-05-18 · Views:1014801

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Not Just Bikes explains why cars rarely crash into buildings in the Netherlands, attributing it to street design that forgives mistakes and to systematic crash investigation. It contrasts this with North American acceptance of such crashes.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it for the systems-over-blame view of road safety and for Dutch infrastructure design.

tl;dw: because they actually do what you suggest, and they incorporate their findings into better road designs. — HN, 2022

Cars, EVs & motorcycles · Transit, cities & urban planning

Subtitles (excerpt)

I've lived in Amsterdam for over a year and a half now and it occurred to me the other day that I haven't seen a car crashed into a building yet it's not that cars never crash into buildings in the Netherlands but it is exceedingly rare and I hadn't seen it or heard of it happening until I went looking for articles about it when we were living in Toronto my son's preschool was here one day we noticed a car had smashed into the drugstore here a place that we walked every day because the streetcar stop was here a few weeks later a car smashed into a pizza shop here on the other side of his preschool incidentally around the same time a speeding SUV ran a red light and knocked over a school bus a few blocks away but that doesn't count here because a school bus is not a building cars crashing into buildings is pretty common in the US and Canada good evening it's a dramatic scene and the third call for a car smashing into a home in a single day in Toronto cars crashed into buildings so often that in many cases it doesn't even make the news I tried to search for a news article about the drugstore buy my son's preschool I couldn't find it but I did find an article about a car crashing into this Shoppers Drug Mart and

On Hacker News

See the YouTube video by Not Just Bikes called “Why Cars Rarely Crash into Buildings in the Netherlands” for an interesting six minute talk about speed, road design and cultural expectations. [VIDEO] — jodrellblank, 2023-06
"Why Cars Rarely Crash into Buildings in the Netherlands": [VIDEO] tl;dw: because they actually do what you suggest, and they incorporate their findings into better road designs. — HellsMaddy, 2022-09
Maybe this is a cause of the increase. But the root cause itself is the really abysmal way we design our streets that creates unsafe conditions. The Not Just Bikes channel addresses this frequently with examples from The Netherlands where they have a stronger focus on acknowledging humans suck and designing for safety, e.g: [VIDEO] — erentz, 2021-07
This is exactly the problem wit the car culture, almost everywhere outside the netherlands. You give cars so much space, they start behaving like it's the freeway, and then drive into buildings or do other stuff which kills drivers and other users. Of course they are speeding, and they shouldn't do that. But the netherlands thinks ahead, and tries not to give cars the opportunity to speed. So, we… — JJzD, 2020-12
This reminds me of this video, about why cars crash into buildings so much in the USA, but not elsewhere: [VIDEO] TLDR It is because in the USA it is blamed on "human error", bad drivers or youngsters going too fast. While in other places, it is seen as a systemic problem, like bad visibility, long stretches of straight roads encouraging speeding, etc. — remram, 2023-07

Related videos