DNI Clapper tells Wyden the NSA does not collect data on millions of Americans

Channel:Ron Wyden · Length:7:06 · Published:2013-03-12 · Views:144579

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Senator Ron Wyden asks DNI James Clapper in a March 2013 Senate hearing whether the NSA collects data on millions of Americans, and Clapper answers 'No, sir... not wittingly.' The question became notable after the Snowden revelations later that year.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it as the key piece of evidence that intelligence officials misled Congress, and as a reported breaking point for Snowden.

Watch this, then ask yourself how you feel — HN, 2013

Privacy, surveillance & cybercrime · US politics & elections

Subtitles (excerpt)

thank you very much uh Madam chair director Brennan first of all congratulations I uh appreciated the chance to talk about a number of issues with you previously and uh I'm going to be asking you some additional questions about drones and targeted killings in the days ahead but for today uh my congratulations director Clapper I want to ask you about what I asked you about a year ago and that was the matter of surveillance and particularly what the rules are that an intelligence agency would have to follow in order to elect ionically track the movements and locations of an American inside the United States and I asked you about this a year ago and you said that your lawyers uh were studying this and I hope that since a year has passed we can get uh some answers uh to these questions so first let me ask uh the question if an intelligence agency wants to electronically track the movements and whereabouts of an American inside the United States how much evidence do they need well first of all let me just say Sir that um particularly in the case of um NSA and CIA um there are strictures against uh tracking American citizens uh in the United States for for foreign intelligence purposes and that's what those

On Hacker News

I've lived under surveillance before, so I feel my perspective might be somewhat appropriate. I won't comment on the specifics (uninteresting and irrelevant, had to do with where I was living). I won't even make a statement about whether it's justified in my case or in general. I'd just ask everyone here to do one thing: Watch this, then ask yourself how you feel (if it doesn't go directly to 6:4… — kevinalexbrown, 2013-06
Wyden is far removed from the part of the government which engages in surveillance. He's the same person who was questioning James Clapper in Congress about mass surveillance before the Snowden leaks [1]. [1] [VIDEO] — sharma-arjun, 2023-12
Maybe. That said, he was one of the few people, who actually made Clapper lie in front the of the entire world. Reportedly, this lie was a breaking point for Snowden who saw the exchange between Clapper and Wyden[0]. While I would be willing to accept your suggestion that is basically just Kabuki theatre, it seems even more cynical than I am willing to contemplate now. I am saying this, because W… — A4ET8a8uTh0, 2020-05
Snowden sacrificed his extremely lucrative career, his access and his ability to live in his own country to expose the illegal and unconstitutional conduct being carried out by the NSA. He put himself in extreme legal jeopardy to expose this illicit government activity and the lies of government officials like James Clapper, who perjured himself before the Senate when asked directly about these a… — StanislavPetrov, 2019-09
In March 2013, the Director of National Intelligence specifically told Senator Ron Wyden that the NSA does not wittingly collect any type of data on millions of Americans: [VIDEO] — DrewHintz, 2013-06

Related videos