Seminar with Alan Kay on Object Oriented Programming (VPRI 0246)

Channel:Yoshiki Ohshima (大島芳樹) · Length:2:41:18 · Published:2017-11-13 · Views:31279

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A long recorded seminar in which Alan Kay discusses object-oriented programming, probably from the mid-1980s. He covers the original idea of objects, messaging and the work done at Xerox.

Why HN recommends it

HN points to it as primary-source evidence of what Kay meant by objects, which resembled services and message passing rather than modern class-based OOP.

Most Alan Kay's presentations I've seen were worth watching. Tons of great ideas in each. — HN, 2019

Software architecture & design · History of computing · Tech pioneers & interviews

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] good idea to put up a slide warning you there might be some IBM jokes of course this isn't I guess this isn't really IBM country out here although I did hear a rumor that you're still programmed in Fortran quite a bit and even the dread word COBOL was heard so maybe it's worthwhile you know object-oriented programming is actually a rather old technology it is just a few years younger in fact than the kind of programming technology that most people are used to that of data structures manipulated by procedures and for various reasons it has not come into currency into vogue until the last couple of years but it's actually about 25 years ago I wrote my first program that I would call object-oriented in 1962 and people have been writing programs in that style even earlier than that in my particular case I was a programmer in the Air Force at Air Training Command in 1962 the there were no standardized operating systems of course that's true today but back then there was actually a reason for it nobody had gotten around to the idea of thinking it it might be useful and Air Training Command had a problem of moving tapes tapes with records of various kinds on them from one Air Training Command base to

On Hacker News

I think this is a fair assessment. I agree that Smalltalk is by far not a complete solution to the problem of building and maintaining complex system but "only" an attempt. I found that message passing is an elegant approach to have interoperability on a very basic level. But when protocols and interactions between objects get more complex, it becomes more difficult retain control and comprehensi… — patterns, 2023-12
Most Alan Kay's presentations I've seen were worth watching. Tons of great ideas in each. They really improved how I reason about systems. There is this famous talk from OOPSLA 1997: [LINK] If you want to see what "practical" OOP looked like in the 80s, this is a good video: [VIDEO] — gambler, 2019-04
This video contains many serious misrepresentations. For example, it makes a claim that Alan Kay only started talking about message-passing only in 2003 and that it was a kind of backpedaling due the failures of the inheritance-based OOP model. That is a laughable claim. Kay had given detailed talks discussing issues of OOP, dynamic composition and message-passing in mid-80s. Some of those talks … — romaniv, 2025-07
> His messages are directed to specific objects, whereas in a biological system, enzymes and the like are dumped into the bloodstream indiscriminately without a specific target. he actually goes into this in one of his (many) talks where he explains what some next steps might be for objects to "sense their environment" and message into the ether so-to-speak very similar to how you describe [0] [0… — andrekandre, 2025-05
That's interesting. Thanks for the paper. I skimmed through it, but I did not get every detail, since it's been a long time I worked with languages like ML or Haskell and my formal background is a bit rusty at the moment. I do like the premise that, if I understood correctly, (1) you want to specify your computations with the most suitable representation(s) and you want them to be inter-operable.… — patterns, 2023-07

Related videos