Feynman: Magnets (and Why?) FUN TO IMAGINE 4/ higher quality version!

Channel:Christopher Sykes · Length:7:34 · Published:2018-09-04 · Views:362271

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A 1983 BBC interview in which Richard Feynman is asked how magnets work and explains why 'why' questions are hard to answer in everyday terms. He reflects on what counts as an explanation and the limits of analogy.

Why HN recommends it

HN returns to it as a model of intellectual honesty and good explanation, often linking it in discussions of why-questions and science communication.

his riff for 8 minutes on this is just a joy to watch. — HN, 2023

Fundamental physics · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

if you get hold of two magnets and you push them you can feel this pushing between them turned around the other way in it then they slim together now what is it the feeling between those two magnets what do you mean what's the feeling I mean that the sensation is that there's something there when you push these two magnets together listen to my question what is the meaning when you say that there's that there's a feeling of course you feel it now what do you want to know what I want to know is what's going on between these two bits of these two bits of metals repel each other and well then what does that but what does that mean or why are they doing that or how are they doing it you're asked I must say I think that's a perfectly reasonable question of course the reason it's an excellent question okay but the problem that you're asking you see when you ask why something happens how does a person answer why something happens for example aunt Minnie is in the hospital why because she slipped she went out and she slipped on the ice and broke her hip that satisfies it people it's size of ice but it wouldn't satisfy someone who came from another planet knew nothing about things you first you

On Hacker News

I linked the "why do magnets do that?" interview elsewhere in the comments, but if anyone else missed it I highly recommend it: [VIDEO] — rimunroe, 2026-02
I disagree! I think fields are very intuitive and it's everything else that's nonsensical! Magnetism isn't made of anything. It is a field, and it's one your can interact with directly. Compare that with, say, table salt. "What's table salt made of?" Uh. It's made of atoms entirely unrelated to salt, like sodium and chlorine. "What are atoms made of?" Uh. They're made of tiny electric particles z… — itishappy, 2024-09
i can't help but tack on my favorite Feynman video, on magnets: [VIDEO] i'm just mesmerized by his answer, that without an understood context, it's not at all easy to explain how magnets work. his riff for 8 minutes on this is just a joy to watch. — dimator, 2023-10
> But the relationship between brain chemistry and consciousness is at best correlating certain conscious states with certain neurological states. How ironic that you would say that in a thread about Daniel Dennett's passing. You have obviously not read "Consciousness Explained." > And QFT explaining laws of nature would be strange considering QFT is included in the laws of nature. You should wat… — lisper, 2024-04
It's an easy mistake to make, to have incorrect pedagogy around the concept of temperature, and Feynman was fanatical about correct pedagogy. This is always good: [VIDEO] — RichardCA, 2021-08

Related videos