Should Knowledge Be Free?

Channel:Medlife Crisis · Length:22:32 · Published:2020-10-14 · Views:1060394

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Medlife Crisis asks whether academic research should sit behind paywalls, covering publisher profit margins, unpaid reviewers, Sci-Hub and Aaron Swartz. It includes an interview with Sci-Hub founder Alexandra Elbakyan.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends it as an informative review of the academic publishing business and its monopoly-like structure.

I found this discussion really informative — HN, 2021

Hacker culture & free software · Free speech, censorship & civil liberties · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

Welcome back to the nightshift. It's shift number 4 and in a fit of narcissistic delirium I decided to search for one of my own publications, but I can’t actually see it without paying. The per-article price is about average, £30 or $40. If you’re writing a paper you might reference 50 studies, which would be a huge expense. Luckily I get access through my university, who are in turn funded by me and other students through fees and by the government. An establishment like UCL will pay around 10 to 12 million pounds a year for subscriptions to scientific journals, most of which belong to just 5 publishing companies. OK, we’re all used to paywalls these days. But for the price of access to my one article, I can get a YEAR of access to The Times AND The Economist (or 2 years of subscription to Nebula and CuriosityStream with the code medlife). And The Times pays its journalists either per article or a salary. But scientific journals don’t produce their own material, scientists do. And they’re not paid by the journal, they’re normally paid by us - the taxpayer. Then journals have people vetting submissions - the peer review process. But, peer reviewers aren’t paid either. They’re other scientists

On Hacker News

The devils are in the details. This does not still justify current model and the steep price they are paid (by taxpayers, FYI a typical university pay millions of dollar to these institutions). Consider openreview by ICLR[1] as an counter example for your claim. The maintenance, quality control, software development is not as steep as current gatekeepers advertise yet their review quality is much… — TaXaZ, 2021-11
The current scientific publication model is only benefits the gatekeepers in publishing industry. It directly goes to the packet of publishing industry by ripping off the tax-payers twice with a steep price. Nowadays research institution pay high fees both for paywall and open-access. No matter you access or publish you some how give tax-payers money to these publishing industries. It has been sh… — TaXaZ, 2021-11
Science Publisher Elsevier's reported profit margin is 38%, compared to Apple's 21% – there's lot of cash at stake for them and a big warchest to defend it For anyone looking to understand the background on the science publishing industry, how it ended up this way and why they will fight Sci-Hub so aggressively, I found this discussion really informative: [VIDEO] — haxiomic, 2021-05
> That pirate bay and scihub are still around, that their authors are walking around freely Let's not equate these sites. scihub gives people what they are likely already paid for. Academic publishing business is a fraud. [VIDEO] (recent video on the topic that I liked) — d0mine, 2020-10
The funny thing is taxpayers ripped twice, on publishing and on access to the science and the profit goes to publication industry (not universities, research institution). If you summarize the cash flow, the publishing industry charges twice the taxpayers in addition to the science worker and research institutions costs. If you want to make your article open access, then you pay extra fees and no… — TaXaZ, 2021-11

Related videos