Apple’s Software Chief Explains ‘Misunderstood’ iPhone Child-Protection Features (Exclusive) | WSJ
Channel:The Wall Street Journal · Length:11:45 · Published:2021-08-13 · Views:365671
Summary
A WSJ interview in which Apple's Craig Federighi explains Apple's CSAM scanning and child-safety features, including neural hashes and safety vouchers, and defends them against backlash.
Why HN recommends it
Mostly cited critically, as Apple's own defense of its scanning plans, which commenters found out of touch or unconvincing; one commenter says it adds nuance.
Cryptography · Privacy, surveillance & cybercrime · Tech pioneers & interviews
Subtitles (excerpt)
- We wish that this had come out a little more clearly for everyone because we feel very positive and strongly about what we're doing, and we can see that it's been a widely misunderstood. - [Joanna] It's not every day an Apple executive admits to widespread confusion over new policies related to fighting child pornography. Yet, here we are. - I grant you, in hindsight, introducing these two features at the same time was a recipe for this kind of confusion. - [Joanna] Last week, Apple introduced new child protection features, one related to spotting and reporting illegal child sexual abuse material, AKA CSAM, or child pornography. And another related to spotting nudes in text messages sent to and often from children. - It's really clear a lot of messages got jumbled pretty badly. - [Joanna] A lot of people got mad and got mad real fast. Not because they don't think child pornography is horrible, but because of the seemingly controversial way Apple was spotting this content and a feeling that the company was crossing the line by scanning the contents of their phones. - I do believe the soundbite that got out early was, oh my God, Apple is scanning my phone for images. This is not what is happening.
On Hacker News
If you watch the Joanna Stern interview with Craig Federighi[1] you’ll find plenty of nuance to contradict your comment. That doesn’t mean you should believe them or that there isn’t a real possibility of the system being abused (that’s partially addressed in the interview), but it also doesn’t mean there was no nuance or thought put into the feature or that it isn’t being misunderstood. All of t… — latexr, 2021-08
> That was just for scanning photos in general. Are you trolling? What Federighi proposed before was scanning "for CSAM" on device [1]. Same angle. > Doing it on device is probably preferable to on cloud and at worst no different. Please elaborate. How is it better to force users to run software they don't want than to let them decide whether or not to have their photos scanned when they choose t… — unityByFreedom, 2022-12
According to them, no. Source: [VIDEO] Side note, I like the quote: Interviewer: Who owns this phone? Craig Federighi: I think our customers own their phones... aaah for sure :P — __warlord__, 2021-09
The part Federighi's "interview" where he can't understand how people perceive this as a back door [1] seems incredibly out of touch. The back door is what everyone is talking about. Someone at Apple should at least be able to put themselves in their critics' shoes for a moment. I guess we need to wait to hear Tim Cook explain how this is not what he described 5 years ago [2]. [1] [VIDEO] [2] [LI… — unityByFreedom, 2021-08
> Steve Jobs must be rolling over in his grave. June, 2010 - Jobs: "Privacy means people know what they're signing up for." [LINK] December, 2015 - Cook: "If you put a back door in, that back door is for everybody, for good guys and bad guys." [LINK] August, 2021 Interviewer: "Isn't this in a way a back door?" Federighi: "I really don't understand that characterization." [VIDEO] — unityByFreedom, 2021-08
Related videos
- Jim Simons (full length interview) - Numberphile · Numberphile2 · 1:00:43
- Steve Jobs Stanford Commencement Speech 2005 · JoshuaG · 14:34
- Behind the Scenes of iOS Security · Black Hat · 51:31
- Why Electronic Voting Is Still A Bad Idea · Tom Scott · 12:00
- But how does bitcoin actually work? · 3Blue1Brown · 25:15
- Alan Kay - Normal Considered Harmful · powerfuloutlet · 1:07:26
- Growing a Language, by Guy Steele · Bill Pugh · 53:31
- A Philosophy of Software Design | John Ousterhout | Talks at Google · Talks at Google · 1:01:40
- Defcon 18 Changing threats to privacy Moxie Marlinspike Part · killab66661 · 42:50
- "Uncle" Bob Martin - "The Future of Programming" · Paul Stringer's Mobile Tech · 1:18:21
- VCF East: Ken Thompson interviewed by Brian Kernighan · Vintage Computer Federation · 1:03:51
- Hamming, "You and Your Research" (June 6, 1995) · securitylectures · 44:02
- Tech Talk: Linus Torvalds on git · Google · 1:10:15
- Alan Kay's tribute to Ted Nelson at "Intertwingled" Festival · TheTedNelson · 17:33
- Joe Rogan Experience #1035 - Paul Stamets · PowerfulJRE · 2:13:48
- "Money doesn't interest me" - Ton Roosendaal 2017 Interview · Blender Guru · 1:46:51