America Always Gets This Wrong (when building transit)
Channel:Not Just Bikes · Length:15:27 · Published:2022-06-20 · Views:2161239
Summary
Not Just Bikes argues that North American transit struggles to attract riders because of the land use around it, not the transit itself. It uses examples such as a London, Ontario line with unreachable stations.
Why HN recommends it
Recommended in transit threads as a clear video essay on why American transit fails: infrequent, isolated and car-oriented surroundings.
great video essay on what north America gets wrong when building transit — HN, 2023
Transit, cities & urban planning
Subtitles (excerpt)
Public transit is pretty bad in North America. It’s inefficient, it’s slow, it doesn’t take you where you want to go and, in most cities – with very few exceptions – nobody takes it, unless they’re really desperate. What’s worse, is that, even when US and Canadian cities do build new transit projects, they often have very low ridership. But if you look at many other cities in the world, public transit actually works pretty well. It’s clean and efficient, and many people happily use it for all kinds of trips. Providing low-cost transportation options, reducing car travel, and generally making the city better for everyone. So what's the difference? We can’t build rapid transit here, our population is too small. If you’ve ever lived in a small to mid-sized US or Canadian city, you’ve probably heard this before. I’ve certainly heard this said in my car-infested hometown of London, Ontario, Canada; a city with no rapid transit at all. Just some infrequent bus service that’s constantly stuck in traffic. A few years ago, there was a discussion in my hometown about building an LRT. That’s the North American codeword for “tram”, because “streetcars” have a bad name. Mostly because they're built wrong and always get stuck in traffic.
On Hacker News
There are several talking points mentioned in this thread that are explored more on the NotJustBikes YouTube Channel. - When Canada built a relatively recent urban rail to Toronto, they built it so you have to drive to the train station , and used the high value land right around the station for ... surface car parking. This is absurdly wasteful of valuable real estate and makes the expensive tra… — jodrellblank, 2023-08
You don't think those elderly people who are having trouble driving would love the opportunity to hold on a light rail line so they can take a stroll downtown in with their grandkids? There is no good transit system in north America. If you want to see good transit you have to go to Europe, Asia or Latin America, where even small towns can have robust transit with high ridership. North America is… — patmorgan23, 2023-02
Definitely! Here’s a video with some discussion [VIDEO] There’s photos of subway stops in random fields in china that sometimes get laughs but in actuality china is just smart enough to build the subway and THEN the buildings. Meanwhile Japanese rail companies own land where they build rail and can make more money on the land than on the trains — CalRobert, 2025-01
We can already have congestion free-cities today, no new technology nor public transport required. We had the technology for quite a while now: congestion charging. It works really well in Singapore to control congestion, and also worked well in London when they adopted it afterwards. Public transport also works quite well in many places around the world. It also used to work really well in North… — eru, 2022-08
I don't think it's that simple [VIDEO] And just because the bay area average is 431 there are plenty of cities in the bay area with much higher densities and there are comparable cities else where that manage to have great public transportation. — asiachick, 2022-07
Related videos
- Why the Dutch Wait Less at Traffic Lights · Not Just Bikes · 10:34
- Joe Armstrong & Jeremy Ruston - Intertwingling the Tiddlywiki with Erlang | Code Mesh LDN 18 · Code Sync · 44:38
- Arcologies · Isaac Arthur · 28:43
- The paradox of choice | Barry Schwartz | TED · TED · 20:23
- DjangoCon 2008 Keynote: Cal Henderson · Google for Developers · 1:02:43
- The Most IMPORTANT Video You'll Ever See (part 1 of 8) · wonderingmind42 · 9:17
- Self-filling water bottle: BUSTED! · Thunderf00t · 16:52
- Why Grocery Shopping is Better in Amsterdam · Not Just Bikes · 3:46
- The surprising science of happiness | Dan Gilbert · TED · 21:20
- Life is easy. Why do we make it so hard? | Jon Jandai | TEDxDoiSuthep · TEDx Talks · 15:10
- The Dutch Solution for Safer Sidewalks - Continuous Sidewalks · Not Just Bikes · 3:44
- Colonizing Mars · Isaac Arthur · 34:32
- The Most Powerful Computers You've Never Heard Of · Veritasium · 20:12
- a better way to count · jan Misali · 18:01
- Tiffany: The Name That Cheats Death · CGP Grey · 8:56
- [EPILEPSY WARNING] How fast should an unoptimized terminal run? · Molly Rocket · 51:03
- I'll Let Myself In: Tactics of Physical Pen Testers · Wild West Hackin' Fest · 44:55
- Why Western Designs Fail in Developing Countries · Design Theory · 27:36
- The Trains that Subsidize Suburbia - GO Transit Commuter Rail · Not Just Bikes · 15:49
- Why This Channel Exists (and why I hate Houston) · Not Just Bikes · 17:02