Linus Torvalds on his insults: respect should be earned.

Channel:TFiR · Length:4:01 · Published:2014-09-04 · Views:721095

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short TFiR clip in which Linus Torvalds explains his view that respect should be earned rather than given, in defense of his blunt and insulting style.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it as the reference for Linus's stance on rudeness and respect in debates about civility and gratuitous negativity.

Software practice, open source & careers · Linux & open-source ecosystems · Tech pioneers & interviews

Subtitles (excerpt)

I'm sorry to ask uh this question almost but it's something that I think is a little bit important um how do you think it affects the culture of a community of a project when the leader is on that project's uh public mailing list telling people in response to patch reviews that they should be retroactively aborted right uh and maybe that you're surprised that they're still alive because they should have starved to death when they were children because they were too stupid to find a pit to suck on I I agree that some people might be put off by that uh but on the other hand you know what I in the end I don't care right um I care about technology and I've actually seen projects that took the whole political correctness so far that the the project no longer is about the technology um I actually so my oh wow we are getting more more questions I think at some point we might want to moderate them so my take don't give me I I actually am very happy to talk about this it's not a problem for me um my standpoint has always been that hey people are different I'm abrasive um I grew up in a culture that I think is not quite as politically correct as the culture especially in the US today um I also grew

On Hacker News

I do agree his language and tone can be very painful to read. Imagine getting called a moron in front of the whole world, when you could have private conversation first with a smaller group. When I read his reply, I could feel the pain. I imagined I would reply back to him and say "well fuck you too." When I finished reading the email, regardless of who is more right or more wrong, I can understa… — yeukhon, 2018-01
Of all replies defending Linus I've read, this one hits home run. Linus himself admits[1] that his outrageous insults are sort of "jokey" and a hyperbole. That's the surface. The underlying tone is to get attention without getting drowned by political correctness. [1] [VIDEO] — fermienrico, 2018-01
People are less creative when they feel disrespected. If you're running a military or places like UPS, where your work value can be boiled down to time and motion studies, it makes a ton of sense to break down people's sense of self: they are being asked to become machines, after all. Torvald's recent screed on Management via perkele , where rudeness is encouraged, interestingly, was born from hi… — nickbauman, 2015-11
[VIDEO] But I honestly fall into the other camp that believes respect should be given freely. BUT that lasts until you open your mouth and say something stupid. I've had "discussions" with people about whether or not MAtz Ruby had a GIL. You don't get my respect for holding that opinion and I have better things to do with my time than worry about your feelings. There's a clear difference between … — mreiland, 2015-04

Related videos